Radio woes still plague homeland security

Status
Not open for further replies.

jimmnn

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 11, 2002
Messages
14,370
Location
Colorado
Radio woes still plague homeland security

Rocky Mountain News
December 6, 2005

Colorado, like the nation as a whole, still falls short on a number of homeland security goals, officials say.

On Monday, the 9/11 Commission gave five F's and 12 D's in grading the nation's response to its 41 key recommendations for preventing and responding to another terrorist attack.

One major problem is the continuing inability of first responders from different jurisdictions to talk to each other over radios.

"It is scandalous that police and firefighters in large cities still cannot communicate reliably in a major crisis," said 9/11 commission Chairman Thomas Kean and Vice Chairman Lee Hamilton in releasing Monday's report.

In Denver, Mayor John Hickenlooper was unhappy to see in a recent disaster drill that this problem has still not been solved here.

The problem stems from decisions some 15 years ago to buy police radios that are incompatible across models and frequencies.

It's as if Cingular and Verizon cell phones could not communicate with each other.

After the Columbine High School killings in 1999, when hundreds of responders had trouble communicating with agencies with different kinds of radios, Colorado began investing more than $130 million in a new state radio system.

The system, though still incomplete, is now used by every state agency and dozens of other emergency agencies, including the Jefferson and Arapahoe sheriffs.

But Denver, Aurora, Lakewood and others have huge investments in radio systems that can speak to each other, but not to the state system.

Denver recently purchased state- of-the-art computer equipment that can translate any incompatible radio calls.

But the recent disaster drill showed that installing the translation device is just the first step.

The individual radios of thousands of first responders in the metro area must undergo minor reprogramming and responders must be trained.

Hickenlooper insisted after the drill that this would become a higher priority.

The 9/11 commission also condemned a federal failure to conduct risk assessments of the nation's critical infrastructure and to fund security improvements.

In Colorado, little has been done on this front, by either the state or the metro area.

Only a dozen or so site-specific security projects have been funded in Colorado, largely in El Paso County.

"There's so much to do, that you can't do everything at once," said Tracy Howard, Denver's acting emergency response manager.

Howard added that radios and other equipment for first responders have been a higher priority.
 

wa8pyr

Technischer Guru
Staff member
Lead Database Admin
Joined
Sep 22, 2002
Messages
7,010
Location
Ohio
jimmnn said:
Radio woes still plague homeland security (snip)
"It is scandalous that police and firefighters in large cities still cannot communicate reliably in a major crisis," said 9/11 commission Chairman Thomas Kean and Vice Chairman Lee Hamilton in releasing Monday's report. (snip)

The problem stems from decisions some 15 years ago to buy police radios that are incompatible across models and frequencies. (snip) Denver, Aurora, Lakewood and others have huge investments in radio systems that can speak to each other, but not to the state system.

At least this story, unlike so many others, correctly points out the fact that the biggest problem is incompatible radio systems rather than a lack of frequencies. The lack of frequencies, to be redressed by the allocation of the 700 MHz TV spectrun (which Congress seems convinced is going to solve the problem) is only a serious problem in really large metro areas.

Even in many large metro areas interoperability capabilities are already in place, but they do not get used for whatever reason. Lack of education and the lack of will to use the capabilities you already have is as much, if not more, a part of the problem than lack of frequencies.

Tom WA8PYR
 

kib669

Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2003
Messages
143
It is amazing to me how the politicians can complain about the lack of ability to communicate between agencies because of limited spectrum and incompatible systems. It only takes a simple system like the Raytheon/JPS ACU1000 to link any type of radio system together. Rather than spending multi-million dollars on DTRS for "everyone", when the ACU1000 can be purchase for less than $30K with radios and a little training. I really makes me mad to see all of the billions of federal dollars being wasted on the "buzz" words of interoperability.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top