It is still going on. Let me tool around for a bit and get a new sample up (the previous sample was from normal scanning, and didn't have digital). I'll record a bit of open squelch and post it in a bit as an edit to this post.
Actually, strike that. I did some searching, and the strongest interference is actually on 856.5000.
It could be TV Audio from Channel 13 (215.7500) or Channel 2 (59.75) or Broadcast FM 107.1. They all line up within about 1Mhz of the base frequencies of 856.5 and 856.5125.
It could also be something else, but tonight all the interference has been music, with no voices. The other night, it was all voices, no music... I'm going to try getting an FM notch filter and see if I can't get it to behave after that. I'd hate to have to undo the new antenna setups since I gained so much other reception.