Your best 'amplifier' is the antenna system itself - namely the antenna and coax. You didn't say much about your setup, but if your antenna is outdoors, nice and high, and you're using a good quality grade coax (RG6 or 9913, for example), you're probably as good as you're going to get.
Putting an amp on a scanner that has as sensitive a front end as the RS/GRE object scanners have can cause more problems than it's worth. In your case, it didn't work - but in many cases, it just adds noise to the system, or worse, causes too much signal for your scanner to handle. That can cause signals to show up where they don't belong (intermod), or in severe cases, cause the radio to lose sensitivity in one or more bands (desense)
I would be cautious about improving the antenna and coax given the sensitivity of that radio, but it's a better shot than adding an amp that might cause more issues than it cures. ..HTH...Mike