ID-5100A as a scanner

707Lineman · Oct 18, 2017

Hi all,
I currently have 2 BCT15X's and I enjoy them. I'm looking for more control of my database, as in groups and whatnot. I found the ID-5100A and really like the the bigger screen and touchscreen function. I monitor everything from CHP to Calfire, ver little aircraft, and police and fire. Would this be a good one to get as a replacement? Not looking to transmit at all, just receive.

PrivatelyJeff · Oct 18, 2017

You won’t be able to monitor any digital radio services that use P25.

707Lineman · Oct 18, 2017

I kinda figured that, both main areas I scan don't use p25 or at least not yet. I'm also concerned about scan speed

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

PrivatelyJeff · Oct 18, 2017

CHP does now

pinballwiz86 · Oct 19, 2017

Scan speed on that Icom is not that fast. It's not designed to be a scanner..

AA6IO · Oct 19, 2017

I have an IC-5100 and it is a nice radio. But not only is scan speed slow, you can't receive below air band. You won't be listening to CHP with the 5100 or other dual band VHF/UHF radios in this category. Also no P25 or trunking. I have many scanners, including the BCT-15X, which as scanners perform better than any of my VHF/UHF amateur radios.

707Lineman · Oct 19, 2017

I agree, I really like the BCT15X, just wish it had a bigger screen like the Icom. Would anybody know of an scanner that has a big screen like that? Been looking but it seems only the VHF/UHF radios have them

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Token · Oct 19, 2017

JeffDS3 said:
CHP does now

And has since 2012 or 2013, but that is primarily for their 700 MHz extenders I think, and the 400 MHz stuff. The VHF-Lo is still analog. The OP list his location as Texas, from there all he is going to hear from CHP is the VHF-Lo. If he is actually in or travels through CA then the extenders have some use.

T!

707Lineman · Oct 19, 2017

Yes, I was aware of that. I'm from Northern California where they primarily use the VHF/Low. Hardly ever hear any activity on the extender frequencies. Yes i currently live in Texas but only listen to CHP when in Northern California. I would love to hear CHP from Texas and currently use Scanner 5-0 app I believe it is.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Token · Oct 19, 2017

707Lineman said:
Yes, I was aware of that. I'm from Northern California where they primarily use the VHF/Low. Hardly ever hear any activity on the extender frequencies. Yes i currently live in Texas but only listen to CHP when in Northern California. I would love to hear CHP from Texas and currently use Scanner 5-0 app I believe it is.

The ID5100 is not going to receive the 700 MHz extender frequencies anyway, so it does not matter if CHP uses P25 on those. CHP does use P25 in some areas on 460 MHz. Border and Coastal regions for sure have some, probably LA? I do not think Northern has any P25 going on, at least it did not the last time I spent any time up there.

Of course every division has the P25 460 MHz stuff available to them, but it is most active in specific areas.

If you are near a CHP office there can be some 460 MHz P25 also.

T!

ID-5100A as a scanner

707Lineman

Member

PrivatelyJeff

Has more money than sense

707Lineman

Member

PrivatelyJeff

Has more money than sense

pinballwiz86

Member

AA6IO

Member

707Lineman

Member

Token

Member

707Lineman

Member

Token

Member

Similar threads