2-meter roll up antennas

I'm looking at the MFJ 2 meter roll up antenna and the N9TAX Slim Jim roll up antenna. I found a lot of reviews for the Slim Jim but they're almost non existent for the MFJ. Has any one had any dealings with either?

I've used the MFJ one for years (probably 10+) when camping. The SWR remains perfect to this day and I would not hesitate to buy another.

No, but considering the MFJ reputation, I’d go with the Slim Jim.