I honestly find this thread to be weird/surprising. My stock G5 antenna works with nearly 100% copy almost anywhere in my county and there's near zero reason I would think to replace it with something else. There are some rather isolated places in my home (i.e. directly behind a steel door) that I've been able to see the (Harris P25 simulcast) system drop out but the vast majority of the time and placement this thing works flawlessly. Wonder if this just varies based on the service your county / system is providing to you. Also I'm not looking to monitor the system from a significant distance i.e. a county over so maybe that helps too.
I agree that the stock stubby antenna generally works just fine (and is prefered if wearing the unit on your belt) within the area of coverage for most simulcast systems... but there are always exceptions.
I myself initially started trying other antennas (the RS 800, Moto, etc.) to "extend" my reception to systems outside my local area where I lived in Maryland. The Moto was a bit better than the stock stubby and the RS 800 did even better than the Moto. With the RS 800, I could receive systems from Harford County MD to Fairfax VA from inside my house.
When driving and monitoring a statewide system, I usually switch to the stubby. In that situation, you don't (most times) want a "better" antenna the causes the radio to stick to a distant site when you've passed others that are closer along the route.
Living here on the southeastern coast on North Carolina, I pretty much must use something better than the stock stubby to receive the two local NC VIPER (non-simulcast) sites which are only 7-8 miles from me.