I have owned and used a handful of PSR-600/500 scanners and their RS siblings, and have never seen such an issue. Of course the only true test is to put multiple scanners on a multicoupler where the can share the same antenna, but if you have the same antenna on each one and they are near one another that should give a decent indication. Are you using the same antenna for testing one scanner against another? Short of a bad connection to the BNC jack, I have my doubts that one of those units will randomly go deaf after years of good service, but anything is possible.