Ah, I see.
Thanks for the ideas, you have me thinking ;-)
I do use a homemade MAST, like yours, it's just a piece of teflon RG-58, a molle buckle, and quite a bit of duct tape.
Two reasons. First. I do need the wide band. In particular, I would like to have both 2 meters, and GMRS (460) in one antenna. I use a dual brander HT when things are easy going, and swap out sabers when things are rough. Hence the wide band. I have (and do) use a tuned antenna with a tail (Smiley) and it works great. The reason for the 152 antenna, is that I can feed it through the molle on my pack (Unlike the smiley, or any dual band antenna I have come across) and it will take a beating.(again, unlike any dual band whip I have found).
Thanks
Matt
KJ6PNN