I have really put my new PRO-197 through it's paces. Both hand programming and computer programming have been used. I have tried just about everything in both base and mobile applications. Here are my thoughts:
PLUS:
- One of the best sounding radios EVER! Better than many Motorola radios I own. It has a clear soft tone without harshness. Great int speaker. And this scanner can get very loud.
- P25 sounded better than my Motorola XTS3000. They made a real effort here and the AGC works perfect!
- AM modulated signals like CB and the Air bands also sound great! Best I have heard out of a scanner.
- All coded squelch action is perfect with a few deep tweaks. Wisper quiet reverse burst. This sounds like a commercial radio.
- Multi-site trunking! Great idea!!! And it works!
- Squelch and P25 NAC code searching is super quick and rock solid. I have not seen a false yet. What great features!
- If you take the time to tweak the advanced features, you can make this radio perfect. Having custom scan delay on EVERY channel is such a cool thing. It makes the scanner work for your system needs.
- Trunking priority, just like a real Motorola, is the bomb! Now I can hear all of my fire dispatches even when someone is gabbing on another trunk channel. Switches right over.
- WX alert features work very well even while scanning! I use WX Priority set to 10 second samples at a check time of 7 and it works perfect! I can depend on it (and I will here in FL).
- Backlighting and custom alert lighting is a nice touch. I get the right light in the truck and the alert lights quickly tell me who I'm hearing.
- The Object memory idea is very good when you understand the concept. It is also like a Motorola in programming. The idea of assigning to scan lists is the perfect solution for flexibility.
- Favorites List is very functional when you want to trim down your normal scan lists to a "cream of the crop" list to speed things up.
- Lots of memory...more than needed in most cases, but the V folder idea works so well for changing the whole personality of the scanner to do different tasks. If you travle it also works well on the fly.
- The menu system takes a little practice to get the new concept, but then it makes perfect sense and is layed out to be fast and easy to use.
MINUS:
- Receiver overload and desense issues ruin this fine scanner in high RF areas. (I'm working on a solution for this issue now)
- Encrypted P25 transmissions sould be muted! That will drive me nuts on the many channels I listen to where it is mixed with "in the clear" transmissions.
- MDC1200 and OTAR should be muted as well. Commercial radios do it (DOS), so why not use that fine DSP engine to do this simple task?
- If you listen to conventional channels which are both P25 and FM with CTCSS/DCS then you need to enter TWO channels to do both or go CSQ open squelch. (I hate open squelch...too noisy!)
- Search features are great, but most of the time I would like to search for CTCSS/DCS/NAC codes without stopping on CSQ noise...noise that hangs up the search.
- Counter hits are hard to view. Way too much menu work to go through just to check each channel.
One thing you should know about with these "objects"...The order you program them in is the order they scan, so if you started out by putting in only a few channels for the different agencies you listen to, and then added more later...and more at other times, your scan order is all mixed up. I do not like that. There is a fix if you use something like WIN500. You can "reassign" them to put them in order, but it is not easy to bounce them around to get them straight. I did it, but what a headache! Now that I have the order down I can "insert" new objects by pushing up the top objects to make room for the new stuff. Now my scanner scans in the order of my scan lists. It also helps focus on the users in each list and scans faster as you are not bouncing around to different bands all of the time.
Really, there is too much to love about this box to put it down. The audio sound, squelch decoding and reverse burst are top notch. The OOS concept is smart and makes sense once you get used to it (read the manual!). Only a few simple changes would make it perfect, otherwise the scanner is FANTASTIC if you are not in a high RF area. If you are, the receiver gets trashed. That is a shame for such a nice scanner. As far as I can tell, most of the inteference causing the high S meter readings, and de-sense, is by VHF-HI TV stations. I love this scanner so much that I'm willing to buy some RF filtering to fix the problem. So much about the scanner is right. I'm looking at the Diamond MX2000 to duck all of the TV and FM bands. You could use one of these with three dedicated Lo/Hi/Uhf antennas, or two filters back to back for one antenna. That would also give you twice as much isolation...which is fine with me, but we are talking about $150 here for the two filters. If I can clean up the receiver, which is sensitive (good thing), I will be very happy with it. 800 NEXTEL and Cellular desense is also a problem. After rebanding is done I hope to get a good bandpass filter to fix that issue as well. It is too bad GRE did not protect the front end of the receiver with better RF filtering. That may hurt them in the long run.
The two most important firmware features I would appreciate would be P25 encryption muting and MDC1200 and OTAR ducking (DOS...mute for duration). Lets hope GRE is watching and helps us out here. I'm not buying every new scanner that comes out. It has to be a big advancement or a really well done scanner to get me to buy! No "spoon feeding" features here! Just do it right the first time or get out of the business.
Phil
