Tough 2 meter antenna request

W8FFG

Newbie
Joined
Apr 17, 2024
Messages
1
Hi all!
I know that this may be a tough one. My Sister WD8HU Mary is a disabled person who lives in an apartment. I set her up with a diamond mag mount antenna with a metal plate on the windowsill in which she can get into a repeater 40 miles away marginally. It has a good low swr. I have racked my brain trying to think of some sort of compact directional high gain antenna that she could use in her apartment to get into the repeater reliably.

Many many thanks in advance for any suggestions.

W8FFG. Bill
 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
26,397
Location
United States
I needed a UHF Yagi to DF some interference. It was at the start of COVID, so it was long lead times for anything I'd order.
I built one of the "tape measure" Yagi's and it worked surprisingly well. Nice thing about it was that it was nearly unbreakable, so as I was driving around taking plots, I could just toss it in the back of the truck.
Might be a good, easy to build option for you, and since it's unbreakable, it's pretty tough.

Bonus points for using the "free" tape measures they are always giving away at Harbor Freight.
 

AB4BF

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
614
Location
EM93cs
Hi all!
I know that this may be a tough one. My Sister WD8HU Mary is a disabled person who lives in an apartment. I set her up with a diamond mag mount antenna with a metal plate on the windowsill in which she can get into a repeater 40 miles away marginally. It has a good low swr. I have racked my brain trying to think of some sort of compact directional high gain antenna that she could use in her apartment to get into the repeater reliably.

Many many thanks in advance for any suggestions.

W8FFG. Bill
Is there any way you could mount the plate at the top of the window and then mount the antenna underneath the plate pointing down? If the window is tall enough, that could give you two to three feet of more height. Just a little bit of height sometimes gives good results. Or, mount the plate on the ceiling or eave if that is where the window is. That would give two to three feet even more height. Just thinking outside the box...
 

hazrat8990

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
503
Location
Wyoming
Any thoughts of building a simple J-Pole?? Quick and easy to build, has a bit of gain, and doesn't require a ground plane.
 

AK9R

Lead Wiki Manager and almost an Awesome Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
10,414
Location
Central Indiana
J-poles are, in essence, end-fed half-wave antennas. They have the same gain as a half-wave dipole. They may have some apparent gain over compromised antennas, such as handheld rubber ducks. With J-poles, you also need to be very careful of their surroundings. The lower quarter-wave portion of a J-pole is a transformer. Metallic objects in the field of that transformer can have negative effects on a J-pole.
 

rf_patriot200

Active Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2024
Messages
1,110
Location
Freeport, Illinois
If J-poles are so good then why are they not currently or ever in the past made by Andrew, Decibel, Phelps-Dodge, Commscope, Comprod, Sinclair, Telewave, etc. and why do you never see them in commercial or government installations?
J poles are Cheap to build and work well. Those companies haven't gotten where they are today by going with "cheap". They LOVE $.
 

mrweather

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
1,326
If J-poles are so good then why are they not currently or ever in the past made by Andrew, Decibel, Phelps-Dodge, Commscope, Comprod, Sinclair, Telewave, etc. and why do you never see them in commercial or government installations?
Never said they worked well. But ham radio is about experimenting and doing things yourself.

I've built a few "copper cacti" over the years and they were durable and worked.
 

Echo4Thirty

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 6, 2021
Messages
1,077
Location
Colorado Springs, CO
If J-poles are so good then why are they not currently or ever in the past made by Andrew, Decibel, Phelps-Dodge, Commscope, Comprod, Sinclair, Telewave, etc. and why do you never see them in commercial or government installations?

Some commercial entity is making them. I see them from time to time for data radio usage. Typically flood or air quality monitors.
 

Echo4Thirty

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 6, 2021
Messages
1,077
Location
Colorado Springs, CO
Pffft. If that were the case they would have all of them on AllStar on the East Coast Reflector!

or or or on all 8 GMRS pairs! lol

Seriously though, is that the reason? I can find ZERO commercial J-poles and have always wondered if they went with a cheap ham antenna and retuned it to the 170s. It woudlnt be the first commercial install I have seen do that.
 

KevinC

Encryption
Super Moderator
Joined
Jan 7, 2001
Messages
13,352
Location
I'm everywhere Focker!
Pffft. If that were the case they would have all of them on AllStar on the East Coast Reflector!

or or or on all 8 GMRS pairs! lol

Seriously though, is that the reason? I can find ZERO commercial J-poles and have always wondered if they went with a cheap ham antenna and retuned it to the 170s. It woudlnt be the first commercial install I have seen do that.
Yes, that's the reason. A lot are now a mobile antenna with a ground plane kit.
 

bill4long

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Messages
1,616
Location
Indianapolis
J-poles are, in essence, end-fed half-wave antennas. They have the same gain as a half-wave dipole. They may have some apparent gain over compromised antennas, such as handheld rubber ducks. With J-poles, you also need to be very careful of their surroundings. The lower quarter-wave portion of a J-pole is a transformer. Metallic objects in the field of that transformer can have negative effects on a J-pole.

J-Poles have a null, which one should be aware of.

1713539180318.png
 

bill4long

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Messages
1,616
Location
Indianapolis
Hi all!
I know that this may be a tough one. My Sister WD8HU Mary is a disabled person who lives in an apartment. I set her up with a diamond mag mount antenna with a metal plate on the windowsill in which she can get into a repeater 40 miles away marginally. It has a good low swr. I have racked my brain trying to think of some sort of compact directional high gain antenna that she could use in her apartment to get into the repeater reliably.

Many many thanks in advance for any suggestions.

W8FFG. Bill

1. Does she have a balcony?
2. Would management allow a small antenna in the attack?
3. How about a vertical dipole hidden up in a nearby tree?
4. Maybe setup a remote using Allstar, IRLP or EchoLink, from her apt to somewhere near the repeater.

Etc. Time to think way outside the box.
 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
26,397
Location
United States
There's no big deal with J-pole antennas. They are 1/2 wave and it's easy enough for a commercial company to build a suitable antenna that works better.

I think the only reason the hams like the J-poles is because they are easy to build with minimal experience. I had one as a new ham and it worked well, but it wasn't anything spectacular.
 

RFI-EMI-GUY

Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2013
Messages
7,646
Hi all!
I know that this may be a tough one. My Sister WD8HU Mary is a disabled person who lives in an apartment. I set her up with a diamond mag mount antenna with a metal plate on the windowsill in which she can get into a repeater 40 miles away marginally. It has a good low swr. I have racked my brain trying to think of some sort of compact directional high gain antenna that she could use in her apartment to get into the repeater reliably.

Many many thanks in advance for any suggestions.

W8FFG. Bill
If maybe she is on the wrong side of the building or a ground floor, perhaps management or neighbor would allow her to install a remote base on that repeater pair in another apartment or common area?
 
Top