How much height do you have in the attic? That is an important factor to consider when looking at antenna specs!
For ham, I have a Diamond X50A in my attic. It's about 5' tall and just makes it. I used a simple plastic conduit strap (two hole strap from the electrical aisle at the hardware store) to attach the top end to a rafter. The bottom end just sits on the attic floor.
I also have a variety of scanner and other antennas up there. Most are NMO style mount vehicle antennas, where I put an NMO mount in a metal plate (square sheet, cookie sheet, pizza plate, etc) to serve as a ground plane.
Of course the nice thing about attic antennas is no need to weatherproof!
Why not build a dual band j-pole out of window line or twin-lead? Lots cheaper and very effective.
K1DU J-Pole
Where we have flooring I can go about 10 ft. I can move to center and have about 20 ft high but have to mount it to the 2x4s that go up to roof.
Do you mind posting or sending me pics of your antennas? I'd be interested in some for scanner as well.
The "best" antenna for the money? If you really want to get out and hit those distant repeaters and/or chase VHF tropo DX, pick up one of those small ELK 2m/440 beams! You can mount it on a small TV antenna rotator inside the attic, and it will dramatically improve your range! I have used it from the inside of hotel rooms when traveling, with very good results.Looking to put an antenna in my attic and get back into it. Looking for suggestions on best antenna for the money.