Hi! I retired from the Coast Guard last year after serving 30-years on active duty mainly in the boat forces-shore station community. Over the years, we used various VHF antenna manufacturers depending on use-case and competitive bidding with contracts. In my time, we've mainly used Metz, Shakespeare, Celwave, and Morad on boats. The legacy shore 'high-sights' used Commscope DB2xx or StationMasters (depending of site specifications) and the Rescue21sites use a mixture of exposed dipole or omnidirectional antennas based on location.
Hands down the most durable antenna of the bunch for small-boat use was the Morad. Shakespeare antennas have a tendency to snap just above the ferrule at highspeeds in short chop. The Morads can withstand a pounding and excessive vibration without degradation. Morads were used for years on both the 44' and 47' Motor-Life Boats (MLB) and serve as a primary AIS antenna on many other cutter/boat classes within the USCG. The MLBs are designed to capsize and then re-right themselves and were spec'd with exterior fittings with would continue to operate post-rollover. You'll also see Morads on many fishing vessels in the PNW. My only complaint with Morad is that there is extra effort involved with weatherproofing the coax connection at the base of the antenna when mounting directly to a ratchet mount. When using a longer support pole, this is not an issue.