I'd love to discuss more over direct message to keep this thread clear, but I'll give a brief summary here.
A lot of it is the same reason Law Enforcement and Security uses Encryption. When covering events, or traveling, while it's highly unlikely people are listening compared to LE's, there are some things we'd just prefer to keep "off the air". Names, phone numbers, specific addresses of where we'll be, etc. Sometimes the radios are used for normal conversations that you'd have on the phone.
While it's not a huge deal, because 99% of the Scanner/Ham community are great people, it's mainly to keep identities and locations private. We're also talking about conventional channels, so the only ones that will hear anything are probably within a mile or two in the city, unless they have a very high antenna dedicated to scanning. The systems we use for countywide or statewide communications we pay for 2 TalkGroups on each system, one Encrypted and one not. Both for the same purpose as conventional.
Having listened to non-encrypted stuff for so long and appreciating the agencies that choose not to encrypt, we try to use our non-encrypted as much as possible for the off-chance that someone might want to listen, as un-interesting as we may be.