If FMP24 is auto-tuning to a signal that is 6.25 kHz off from the channel you're tuned to, your bandwidth setting is too large or your PPM adjustment value is wrong. FMP24 won't auto-tune to what it can't see, so obviously it's seeing the other signal, which means it's mixing that signal with your target signal and causing interference / degraded decoding, even without the auto-tuning issue.