Ham Radio Crash

AC0RV

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Dec 19, 2000
Messages
1,620
Location
Park Hills, MO
How follows "watches" the Ham Radio Crash Course ???

I find it generally its a good show.
 

KE0GXN

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2011
Messages
1,339
Location
Echo Mike Two-Seven
I watch it from time to time. Nothing wrong with obtaining information from various sources. Like anything else, the key is doing your due diligence and verifying the information is accurate before applying it or using it. Much like advice given in this place or any other fourm, etc..

As far as lids....LOL...just tune to the choice “neighborhoods“ on 20, 40 and 80 meters.....I think we can all agree those aren’t “Youtube-ers” espousing the vulgarities and overall malfeasance that occurs on those frequencies or the many other jamming/stupid activities that occur all over the bands. :rolleyes:
 

k6cpo

Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2013
Messages
901
Location
San Diego, CA
It's just like almost all the other ham radio YouTube channels.
He leaves out a lot of things and gets a lot of things wrong.
If you rely on YouTube stars to teach you ham radio you will end up a stupid lid.
There are some good amateur radio content providers on YouTube, but they're few and far between. You have to really carefully filter what you see. Most ham radio videos on YT have very poor production values, such as shaky out-of-focus camera work, bad narration (too many "umms...") and poor knowledge of the subject matter.

One thing I've notice about the Ham Radio Crash Course and his associates is they all seem obsessed with Baofeng.
 

R8000

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
763
Take them with a grain of salt. Especlly the ones that preach "be sure to like and $ub$cribe !". The hams who are just into YouTube for the money stand out like a sore thumb. I block them so they never get recommended to me again. The over dramatized intros, editing, graphics are just bling to get you to $ub$cribe.
 

2IR473

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
59
In many ways, HRCC and the other YouTubers are trying to appeal to younger hams, and that’s ok.
Ham radio could use some new hipsters, rather than all the replacement hips it has had for decades.
 

AK9R

Lead Wiki Manager
Super Moderator
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
6,675
Location
Central Indiana
Liking YouTube videos and subscribing to YouTube channels plays into the algorithms that determine whether or not those videos or channels show up in search results. The beast kinda feeds on itself. The more likes or subscribes a YouTuber gets, the more likely their videos will be "found" by the system, so the more views they get, etcetera, etcetera. And, YouTube monetization is based on views, likes, and subscribes.

Since there are many YouTubers whose primary source of income is YouTube, I don't begrudge those who ask me to like and subscribe. That's how they make money.

But, I am skeptical of product "reviews" when the content creator doesn't say if they bought the product with their own money or if some manufacturer or retailer sent them the product for review. It's like KJ4YZI's (HamRadioConcepts) recent videos about the Icom IC-705. That radio isn't available from dealers yet, so how did Eric get one to review? I haven't watched all of the review videos all the way through, but I'll jump to the conclusion that as a result of his relationships with Icom and Gigaparts, he got a pre-release radio to review. Does that make his review any less honest? I don't know. I think Eric is fairly honest in his reviews. Would I be more comfortable with his reviews if he said up front that Icom or Gigaparts sent him the radio? Yes.

Yes, it is good that a younger generation of hams is producing online content that appeals to a younger generation of hams. I'm an "old fart" with almost 30 years in amateur radio, but I think I realize that we need KI6NAZ, KJ4YZI, and others appealing to the younger audience. I just hope that these young whippersnappers realize that even though there are probably topics that they understand better than I do, there are still a few things us old farts could teach them.
 

tweiss3

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Apr 24, 2020
Messages
265
Location
Ohio
In many ways, HRCC and the other YouTubers are trying to appeal to younger hams, and that’s ok.
Ham radio could use some new hipsters, rather than all the replacement hips it has had for decades.
To be honest, I do attribute HRCC as the reason I decided to go for my HAM license. However, I started studying, and realized there isn't much good information on youtube. I studied myself with the ARRL books, and added the local radio's curriculum and punched T+G at once. I would say I'm on the younger side of HAM, eating up all the knowledge the local elmers offer.

I did find out that HRCC is affiliated with Brian Brushwood and all his entertainment stuff, so take that as you will. Actually, that's probably how his videos, since I watch all the ScamSchool stuff when I have a free moment.

Liking YouTube videos and subscribing to YouTube channels plays into the algorithms that determine whether or not those videos or channels show up in search results. The beast kinda feeds on itself. The more likes or subscribes a YouTuber gets, the more likely their videos will be "found" by the system, so the more views they get, etcetera, etcetera. And, YouTube monetization is based on views, likes, and subscribes.

Since there are many YouTubers whose primary source of income is YouTube, I don't begrudge those who ask me to like and subscribe. That's how they make money.

But, I am skeptical of product "reviews" when the content creator doesn't say if they bought the product with their own money or if some manufacturer or retailer sent them the product for review. It's like KJ4YZI's (HamRadioConcepts) recent videos about the Icom IC-705. That radio isn't available from dealers yet, so how did Eric get one to review? I haven't watched all of the review videos all the way through, but I'll jump to the conclusion that as a result of his relationships with Icom and Gigaparts, he got a pre-release radio to review. Does that make his review any less honest? I don't know. I think Eric is fairly honest in his reviews. Would I be more comfortable with his reviews if he said up front that Icom or Gigaparts sent him the radio? Yes.

Yes, it is good that a younger generation of hams is producing online content that appeals to a younger generation of hams. I'm an "old fart" with almost 30 years in amateur radio, but I think I realize that we need KI6NAZ, KJ4YZI, and others appealing to the younger audience. I just hope that these young whippersnappers realize that even though there are probably topics that they understand better than I do, there are still a few things us old farts could teach them.
I agree, I see BridgeCom really really pushing their 878 HTs. I find the Youtube content is good for seeing the size of units, displays, menu structure, and mostly the programming methods (but you do learn more when its in hand). Beyond that, the "opinion" of the reviewers is just that, and opinion. You still have to make your own decision and compare to the competitors and your set maximum price.
 

royldean

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
435
Location
Schwenksville, PA
I did find out that HRCC is affiliated with Brian Brushwood and all his entertainment stuff, so take that as you will.
I used to enjoy "Hoshnasi" more when he did actual "stuff", rather than just showcasing products. I'm not sure what this "Brian Bushwood" connection is, though. (I had to google his name). What is the deal with him? What is the connection between the two?
 

W5GX

Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2018
Messages
73
I used to enjoy "Hoshnasi" more when he did actual "stuff", rather than just showcasing products. I'm not sure what this "Brian Bushwood" connection is, though. (I had to google his name). What is the deal with him? What is the connection between the two?
I'm only aware of a connection since Brian had Josh as a guest on his Youtube channel "The Modern Rogue". Great channel, I think - very entertaining. And they're in Austin, so that's an extra bonus for a native. :p
 

JDrisc3480

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2010
Messages
188
Location
Shannon, North Carolina
I watch Ham Nation and Amateur Logic all the time. I don't know what it is but I enjoy these two shows. I tried to watch HRCC but just could not get into it for some reason.
 

K9DWB

QRT
Joined
Aug 7, 2020
Messages
288
Location
Greencastle, PA, USA
I've watched a few HRCC and I get some value on the info. I take what I want out of his videos and what I don't value gets dropped/filtered out. I first watched some Ham Radio Concepts with Eric/KJ4YZI in FL. His are interesting to me, and did help feed my interest in Amateur. HRC/Eric had a video on Amateur radio beginners and CB use. I used to be a truck driver and had several CBs in my 11 years as a Class A CDL driver. All were stock for a few minutes. So I was a bad CBer. It is past though.

I am now a new Tech class Amatuer with a new Yaesu FT3DR HT, and there's plans to get the General ticket next month. I thought the info from these combined videos was a good place to start. I've also caught a few Ham Radio 2.0 with Jason and some Goodgame and David Casler YouTubes. All are helpful to me but each in a different way.
 

Fenrir

Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
2
I like HRCC as well as a few others. It got me interested and motivated in the hobby. I’m new to it all but getting more people involved can’t necessarily be a bad thing.
 
Top