I have a Home Patrol I and like the HP2, the internal speaker is quite anemic. I've tried a few different solutions (modifying an existing Astatic external speaker to include a 10-watt amp, bluetooth adapter to stream the line output). Nothing sounded satisfying. The BC23A with the above referenced 12v AC adaptor along with the auto-off modification worked very well. The sound is wonderful with digital broadcast, but it's the analog broadcasts that needed help. There is a richer, more full-range sound on this speaker than I expected - not tinny or overly "bassy."
This has prompted me to order a second BC23A set up, as this has worlked out well. Thanks to everyone for all of the information!