Hi X Marine and all,
Tin foil on the antenna? That reminds me of my TV repair days when I saw people putting it on the "rabbit ears" thinking they could do better than the RF engineers had done. Now that my hysterical laughter has subsided...
Nothing beats a good antenna topside but whatever you do PLEASE avoid agrivation from the start, don't use some "booster" to amplify signals. Without getting all technical on you, they're the best source of intermodulation interference ever devised by the mind of Man. If you must use an indoor or back of set antenna there's rather little you can do to improve reception all things considered.
You're satisfied for the most part so follow the first rule of plant maintanence, if it ain't broke don't fix it. Try all the antennas you like, you might hit upon something better for your purpose but don't try to out-do the engineers, save the tin foil for the hat. (;->)