rbm
Member
I've used my X-Wing antenna for a few years and it performs quite well considering the cost.
But, I don't leave it set up constantly.
Whenever I want to use it, I drag out the ground plane and place the antenna in the center of it. On the ground.
The other day (while I was dragging it out yet again) I was wondering how much difference a smaller ground plane would make. Or even better, NO ground plane at all.
So, I captured a screenshot with and without the ground plane.
Some things to keep in mind.
My X-Wing sits right on the ground, or very close to it.
I have an LNA-580 low noise preamp mounted inside the PVC base of the antenna.
If you aren't using a preamp, you'll need to crank up the RF gain in SDRSharp by around 15 dB to come close to the same signal levels.
I used SDRSharp to capture the images just a few minutes apart.
Nothing at all was changed except for the ground plane.
So, if you ever thought about building an X-Wing but were put off by the big ground plane, you may want to rethink that.
Rich
X-Wing WITH the ground plane:
X-Wing with NO ground plane.
But, I don't leave it set up constantly.
Whenever I want to use it, I drag out the ground plane and place the antenna in the center of it. On the ground.
The other day (while I was dragging it out yet again) I was wondering how much difference a smaller ground plane would make. Or even better, NO ground plane at all.
So, I captured a screenshot with and without the ground plane.
Some things to keep in mind.
My X-Wing sits right on the ground, or very close to it.
I have an LNA-580 low noise preamp mounted inside the PVC base of the antenna.
If you aren't using a preamp, you'll need to crank up the RF gain in SDRSharp by around 15 dB to come close to the same signal levels.
I used SDRSharp to capture the images just a few minutes apart.
Nothing at all was changed except for the ground plane.
So, if you ever thought about building an X-Wing but were put off by the big ground plane, you may want to rethink that.
Rich
X-Wing WITH the ground plane:
X-Wing with NO ground plane.