How would you rate the data / info on this website?

Status
Not open for further replies.

scanmanmi

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Sep 25, 2011
Messages
843
Reaction score
183
Location
Central Michigan
I am curious about your experience with the frequency data / info on this website. I'm really impressed with the exception that most of my local frequencies are wrong. Is there a similar website where I can find frequency info? I am reluctant to subscribe when there are such blatant mistakes. How is the data gathered? Just by volunteer listeners?
 

W8VFD

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Jul 8, 2005
Messages
202
Reaction score
14
Location
Northeastern Ohio
I am curious about your experience with the frequency data / info on this website. I'm really impressed with the exception that most of my local frequencies are wrong. Is there a similar website where I can find frequency info? I am reluctant to subscribe when there are such blatant mistakes. How is the data gathered? Just by volunteer listeners?



Yes, the data is gathered by volunteers, if you have the correct frequency data for your area please feel free to submit it, others in your area would appreciate it as well.
 

GTR8000

NY/NJ Database Guy
Database Admin
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
16,595
Reaction score
15,353
Location
BEE00
The data is gathered by people like you. If you know there are incorrect listings for your county/local area, then put a list of corrections together and submit them. There is a big Submit Info button at the top of every page on the site on the blue navbar. You've been a member of the site for a year now, and I see you haven't made any submissions. Maybe it's time to make your first and get some of those "blatant mistakes" fixed so the next guy who comes along will benefit from your knowledge.
 

loumaag

Silent Key - Aug 2014
Joined
Oct 20, 2002
Messages
12,935
Reaction score
11
Location
Katy, TX
Based on your post from August 4th, I see you are from MI. It is quite possible that you are looking at your county data on your county page and it is outdated or retained for backup purposes as most of the state is on the MPSCS. If you don't understand how trunking works in general, may I suggest a review of the Trunking Basics article on the RR Wiki; it is really pointed at the complete neophyte, but if you slog through it, things will become clearer.
 

scanmanmi

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Sep 25, 2011
Messages
843
Reaction score
183
Location
Central Michigan
Thanks Lou
Everybody in Michigan and their brother is migrating to the P25 system which I know nothing about. I live in Clare County and there is also a city named Clare. The Clare County page mentions the city uses P25 but they are not listed on the P25 page. There is no mention of the County police moving to P25 but they ARE listed on the P25 page. Some of the listings on the P25 must be future use because they still have fire & ambulance dispatch, EMS-hospital on VHF. What does "Clare Police - Proprietary Law Talk" mean? On old VHF scanners you could scan and pick up a freq, listen and figure out who it was. How in the world can you randomly scan 800 mhz and figure anything out? Seems like you would have to have the info before you start.
 

loumaag

Silent Key - Aug 2014
Joined
Oct 20, 2002
Messages
12,935
Reaction score
11
Location
Katy, TX
Thanks Lou
Everybody in Michigan and their brother is migrating to the P25 system which I know nothing about. I live in Clare County and there is also a city named Clare. The Clare County page mentions the city uses P25 but they are not listed on the P25 page. There is no mention of the County police moving to P25 but they ARE listed on the P25 page. Some of the listings on the P25 must be future use because they still have fire & ambulance dispatch, EMS-hospital on VHF. What does "Clare Police - Proprietary Law Talk" mean? On old VHF scanners you could scan and pick up a freq, listen and figure out who it was. How in the world can you randomly scan 800 mhz and figure anything out? Seems like you would have to have the info before you start.
Let me address the Clare Co SO and Clare City issue first. The Clare PD appear to be using a channel on the system which is reserved for them. This seems to be something used throughout the system and called "Proprietary" although why I don't know, you would have to ask the regional DB Admins that question. I am assuming this means they don't share the channel with anyone else. The fact that all the towns in Clare Co. who are using the state P25 system are listed in the county block, this is quite common in the DB unless the local town has lots of talk groups (TGs).

Now as to still being on VHF, that doesn't preclude them from being on the MPSCS system also. Quite often, especially in a transition period, the old VHF (or UHF) conventional channels will be patched to the appropriate TG on the trunking system and the transmissions can be heard on either. The reason, well those P25 trunking radios are not cheap and sometimes an agency cannot afford to move everybody at the same time. This is especially true in regard to volunteer EMS and Fire departments.

As for looking for "new" TGs, well all the TGs you see listed are found the same way, someone listened, noticed a new TG, monitored it (or recorded it) until they figured out what it was then submitted it to the DB for inclusion. Note, that is exactly what you described as the process in the "old" days. How to do it, well you need to understand the whole trunking concept first. Then there are several software packages out there (for free) that will allow you to monitor and record new TGs on a TRS. Some require two radios, some one. It all depends on what radio you are using and how interested you are in the process. A pretty fair one for use with Uniden radios that only requires one radio and still allows you to actually listen while it works is IDTracker (comes in 3 versions) depending on radio model and type. But all of this, I think, is beyond your initial question and followup.
 

W8VFD

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Jul 8, 2005
Messages
202
Reaction score
14
Location
Northeastern Ohio
How in the world can you randomly scan 800 mhz and figure anything out? Seems like you would have to have the info before you start.


A properly programmed trunking scanner on a trunked system will tell you who is talking at any given time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top