INEXPENSIVE (but decent) - Is that too much to ask for?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
2,406
Reaction score
2,914
Location
Washington State
I recently purchased an RTL-SDR, but the el-cheapo antenna it came with leaves much to be desired. Here's the thing though, this is like a sub-sub hobby to me, definitely not my primary hobby. With that in mind, I'm not looking to spend 2, 3 or 4 times more for an antenna than I did for the dongle. Since an antenna is just a few pieces of metal, the prices I've been seeing don't "cut the mustard" with me. So, has anyone located a decent VHF/UHF antenna for a more down to Earth price that has decent specifications?
 

DS506

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Sep 24, 2011
Messages
108
Reaction score
62
Location
Ohio
Have to laugh...Years ago I helped my wife get a TV/VHS combo for their office to use. I visited later and they had made about a five foot long chain of paper clips, put packing tape on both sides to keep them together, stuck the first one in the center hole of the of the F jack. Taped the other end to the top of a filing cabinet. IT WORKED! Picked up all three local stations.
 

MTScannerNut

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2017
Messages
135
Reaction score
70
Location
NW Montana
I've been pretty happy with my Diamond Discone antenna that cost around $110 if I recall correctly. Been up through five Montana winters so far with no issue.

My return on investment has been pretty good so far I'd say. My other hobby is a lot more expensive lately. I think that's what a box of .22 LR costs nowadays isn't it ;)
 

jazzboypro

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
1,075
Reaction score
409
Location
Laval
I recently purchased an RTL-SDR, but the el-cheapo antenna it came with leaves much to be desired. Here's the thing though, this is like a sub-sub hobby to me, definitely not my primary hobby. With that in mind, I'm not looking to spend 2, 3 or 4 times more for an antenna than I did for the dongle. Since an antenna is just a few pieces of metal, the prices I've been seeing don't "cut the mustard" with me. So, has anyone located a decent VHF/UHF antenna for a more down to Earth price that has decent specifications?

Actually the antenna is the most important part of your setup and it's where a good part of your budget should go if you want to enjoy this hobby.
 

Ubbe

Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2006
Messages
11,023
Reaction score
4,723
Location
Stockholm, Sweden
Since an antenna is just a few pieces of metal, the prices I've been seeing don't "cut the mustard" with me.
That's so true. A single band dipole antenna can be built with just some electrical wire and hang up in a window or in the attic and will probably cost you less than one dollar. The only difference from the ones you can buy for $100 and upwards are that they are mechanically much better done that can withstand harsh outside enviroments for many years, but are not needed for indoor use.

Making multiband antennas are a bit more difficult. But making a dipole for the systems frequency that are the weakest in signal strength could sometimes still receive the stronger systems satisfactory in other frequency bands. It's just some more electrical wires if you experiment with different dipoles that you probably will afford. The most important thing are hight above ground.

/Ubbe
 

merlin

Active Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2003
Messages
3,961
Reaction score
1,905
Location
DN32su
These cheap dongles are technically nothing more than the tuner in your TV. One of those old log type TV antennas re-mounted vertically is hard to beat. The downside is they tend to be directional. (sometimes a good thing)
The discone was designed as an omni-directional TV antenna and became popular in the scanner market.
Band specific, those droopy ground planes can be home made for about $10. Like the TV antenna, they are not much use unless mounted as if a TV antenna- outdoors, above the roof. One good part is one made for VHF also works well for UHF. The OC fed dipole suggested by ka3jjz works great. same thing though.(higher is better)
>>CABLE> TV coax works just fine but keep the length just for what is needed, longer means more loss.
TV and FM broadcast, you are hearing stations nearby and over 1 KW power. the fun stuff is like dialing in railroad, police and amateur and now you are talking much lower power, like talkies or 30 watt repeaters.
In this fact, adding a 'GOOD' LNA in line helps a lot.
Now these dongles do work, but they will never compare to a receiver made for the job.
They need all the signal you can gather or they don't hear it.
They have no filtering in the front end making interference and noise a real problem.
My RTL-SDR setup, I have come a long ways, from a discone on the roof into an LNA, then into a preselector with filtering and attenuation. I scavenged and built much of this and over time, maybe another $150 invested.
I use a couple different softwares, DSD+fastlane is not so expensive, but I do so much with it.
I really have little time to just sit and mess with it but do. Like you, not a primary hobby.
This setup also serves as bench test equipment working on radios. (a poor man lab)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top