Ok thanks, I was wondering what the SLATER type was, appreciate the help. Guess I'm going to try to decide on one of those two models as I believe they both do p25. Debating on going cheaper also with the bc160 and just taking the loss of it's abilities.
Main question is, what's your budget if you don't mind me asking?
I Live in St. Louis County (South Area) and the BCD436HP doesn't do well with the simulcasting. I recently got an SDS100 as a birthday present and I can safely say I'm amazed on how good it does.
Since Jefferson County is the same way, the 436 might work as mine worked a bit better in the JeffCo area (I go there a lot for reference).
If you have the budget, I'd say that you should go with an SDS which is priced at $650 at the moment. If you don't, a 436HP or 325P2 will work decently as well.
Also as jtwalker has said, it cannot do trunking which is a bit of wasted potential for that scanner in my opinion. There are some stuff analog in the area such as fire dispatch and the warning siren data frequencies. But its best to future-proof.