May Need A New Receiver....

Status
Not open for further replies.

RANGERDALEXP

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
36
Location
Palmdale, Ca.
I posted this question at the tail end of my question in the Icom thread, I may need to look into a good replacement for my Icom IC-R71a that has come down with some problems. It may just not be worth fixing it and I need suggestions on a new replacement. I do not do any transmitting but I like to listen. I am looking at a price range of less then $500 to a $1000 dollars and only will consider a good quality machine.

I presently have been looking at the Icom IC-R75 but would like to look at other manufactures as well as any comments before choosing.

Thanks for any suggestions....
 
Last edited:

RANGERDALEXP

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
36
Location
Palmdale, Ca.
Do you want stand alone? I.E. not computer controlled such as an SDR? Also do you want new or would you consider used?

T!

Something in line like the Icom R75 and would like a new one for warranty issues. I do not really want an obsolete model that is no longer supported like the problems I am having now with the Icom R71a. The R71a in full working order is only worth $200 to $300 and I understand even If I find a guy to fix it, it could cost that much in repairs. As of now I cant even find a guy to look at it and the place I bought it from which was the Ham Radio Outlet store in Burbank was not much help....

Short wave listening is kind of a dying art now and I have been out of it for so long I do not know what is good anymore? I just know that I set up all my scanner stuff and would like to include a good SW radio like I planed before finding out that the R71 now has a problem with its audio...

Maybe I would consider a used one as long as it is in good shape and only a few years old but that all depends on price, the last time I bought a used Sony portable sw radio it took a dump 3 days latter.

I just do not want a piece of junk and something good......
 

RANGERDALEXP

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
36
Location
Palmdale, Ca.
I guess there is no one that knows much about this type of equipment or has any opinions. I guess I will just take a guess on what to get?
 

Token

Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2010
Messages
2,450
Location
Mojave Desert, California, USA
Something in line like the Icom R75 and would like a new one for warranty issues. I do not really want an obsolete model that is no longer supported like the problems I am having now with the Icom R71a.


For the price range you posted, from less than $500 to $1000, the choices new are fairly limited.

The Icom R75 you have already mentioned. Probably the best stand alone receiver in the price range you have quoted. If you really want a traditional tabletop radio with knobs then the R75 is hard to beat. The audio improves if you use an external speaker, as the internal is a little small.

The Palstar R30A is a bit more expensive than the R75 but still in your price range. It is better than the R75 in some ways, but not others. In my opinion the R75 is a better complete package.

There is a new Alinco, the DX-8RT, that is in your price range. It combines a sound card SDR with a traditional knob tuned radio. But, it is really new and not too many reviews out on it yet. I have not used one personally.

And those are about it for what you have described, a new desktop SW radio under $1000.

Now, the selection expands a bit if you include computer controlled radios and SDRs.

The WinRadio G31DDC Excalibur is an excellent SDR and runs about $900 or a little less. In my opinion this is possibly the best sub $1000 radio on the market today.

The RFSPace SDR-IQ is a very good radio for the price, $500, again an SDR. Not perfect mind you with some shortcomings, but generally as good as the R75 in most ways and better in several.

The WinRadio G303e is a computer controlled receiver that the manufacturer calls an “SDR”, but it probably should not carry that label. It is, however, a good radio for the cost, about $600. Its big brother, the G313e, is a really good radio, but over your cost bracket.

The Ten Tec 320D is a low cost decent computer controlled radio. Not quite up to the others discussed, but a good bit less expensive.

If you move the cost window up some there are a few more options, both in tabletops and SDR/computer controlled. But really there are some good units in your cost range.

Seriously, if I could only buy one SW radio right now, and it had to be under $1000, I would opt for the WinRadio G31DDC Excalibur. The problem is it is an SDR and that means it must be connected to a computer to work at all. And then the question arises, in 10 years will you be able to put together a system to support the radio, one with an OS that is compatible and the correct com port. To me the Excalibur performance is worth the fact that 10 years from now I might not be able to use it, others might not share that sentiment.

If you have to have a traditional tabletop with knobs then the R75 is a very good choice. I quite like mine, but as I am hooked on the SDR concept the R75 ends up doing backup duty most of the time.

T!
 
Last edited:

RANGERDALEXP

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 8, 2009
Messages
36
Location
Palmdale, Ca.
This is good information and I will look at all of it. I am glad you did not mention any of the E-Ton stuff since it all seems to look like junk from what I can see. I will look at the SDR stuff but would like the ability to grab the radio and take it with me if needed.....

Thanks Token
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top