I have been responsible for a slew of DTR410 radios at three different sites for several years now. The 410 has the shorter antenna and a range of about 1 mile. My sites are in heavily wooded areas with some slight hills and valleys. The requirement was for a radio that was hard to hear with a "cheap Radio Shack scanner", loud audio, and build quality like their older Motorola CP200 handhelds. The DTR series is rugged, has loud audio and is not easily heard on a scanner. You would need some very good gear to hear these as they frequency hop and use VSELP.
Sites are schools and they are used about the campus. DTR radios were sold as being able to penetrate buildings and multiple floors of buildings. They seem to do this well and have good range about the campuses.
I also had the eXRS radios and tested them in a rural environment. They lacked the durability and range of the DTR radios.They also had a problem of losing sync with each other when they lost connection. Also if you had some eXRS radios synced to each other and then later on tried to add another to the group, I had to power cycle them all about the same time to join the group.
The Motorola DTR radios just work, and work well. If you go with DTR radios, be sure to put your own network ID number in and do not use a default. I use one to ping around town and many construction sites can be heard since they use the default.