The fact that neither of the other antennas seem to hear the noise makes me wonder if the hardline on the tower along with the coax jumpers may be part of the problem. Namely, if there happens to be a bad connection (probably the shield) causing noise to leak in. The SWR can read OK but there still could be a questionable connection. This part of "8-Land" is currently in the midst of an ice storm, but when weather improves, the OP may want to take a look at the various connections. Perhaps jumper around the entry panel (from the hardline to the radio} with a known good length of coax.