During the transition from all cops to civilian dispatchers, in the late 1970s, early '80s, it wasn't too bad to work down there. The cop "influence" as well as their "street experience" (for some of them, but not all of them) was an important part of the operation. All of the operational and administrative bosses were Sergeants and Lieutenants.
The first "wave" of civilians were actually the Police Administrative Aides (PAAs) who came from administrative jobs in the precincts themselves, so they brought a certain "cop" attitude (and experience) with them. In some cases, the relationship between these dispatchers and the cops in the street went as far as to being social, with the Dispatchers being invited to retirement and promotion parties, etc.
But then the PD opened the job up to anyone who could type xx-words per minute and who held any job at anytime in their past lives, people with little or no life experience, much less police experience, as a "social experiment": if more people with NYPD ID cards were in "the neighborhoods," they could influence that "neighborhood" into accepting the police.
It didn't work. In fact, it sort of backfired.
At that point, instead of having people who realized and acknowledged that they were an integral part of the police operation, you had people who looked at it as just a job. Whether they were inputting a serious police job, or handling a customer service call for a credit card company, it was all the same to them.
During a second or third day of training class for new "PCTs" many years ago (a class given by cops), the instructor happen to mention just in passing something about "working midnights...." At that point, one of the new recruits raised her hand and said, "You mean, we have to work nights?" The instructor said, yes, of course.
Seven new recruits got up and left.
With all that being said, it tells me there's a reason why they "waived" the residency requirement, opening up the job to a more diverse and experienced (volly FD or EMS, small-town police dispatchers, etc) applicant pool.
We can only hope.....!