Some help.....
O.K. I'm not from Indiana but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
Give this programming shortcut page a read
Programming Shortcut pro-2096 - The RadioReference Wiki and try to follow the instructions then check back and let us know your results. It should get you up and running, if not we can work on any additional issues.
I assume you have gone to the Database here for all the Indiana SAFE-T info. It looks like you really only need to enter two Control Channel freqs for Johnson Co. to follow the action. Then of course you will need to select which TalkGroups you want to hear and get them entered as well. The big thing is setting both the desired BANK and FREQUENCY/CHANNEL to "MOT" so the scanner knows what it should do.
With such a large system as you have in IN you may want to look into investing in the programming cable (the new one is about $35 but the 2096 can be loaded using the older no longer available cable that sometimes can be found on ebay, I got one for $5. The part # for the older one is 20-289) and some software, most folks here use Win96 from starrsoft.com
Check back and let us know how you do.......
Good luck,
Tom