Sell it! Get a 106, it'll do a little better job on ORION.
The Pro 96 doesn't digest CQPSK modulation very well, when you throw in a multi-zone system such as ORION, which simulcasts over 6 towers in the Omaha area, Pro 96 get rather "confused", and doesn't lock on the appropriate tower. It attempts to decode the digital signal from several towers.
However Pro 96 does well with C4FM modulation, such as what is used on the Colorado DTRS.
If you have a "real" radio such as the Motorola Astro line, it has the capability to "clean up" the simulcasted transmissions, producing audio that is intelligible, no matter where you are as long there is suitable signal strength that allows good decode rate and the radio is assigned to the respective tower.
I'm in Bellevue, and I don't have any real issues with ORION on my Pro96. I have tried all upgrades and V1.2 and works best for me. 1.4 seem to have made the reception worse.