Scanner Tales: The Magazines

As an old guy I still remember getting monthly magazines printed on real paper every month. Some of these were special and anxiously awaited. Monitoring Times, the RCMA Scanner Journal and Popular Communications were the “Big 3” in the scanner community. There have been and are still some others but for better or worse these were the biggest by far. Of course, all three are long gone now.

My personal favorite was The Scanner Journal published by the Radio Communications Monitoring Association (RCMA). This was what RadioReference is today, but in a paper format. Every month there was a magazine printed and mailed to your home, chock full of frequencies and information gathered by the best volunteers in the hobby. I joined and subscribed in the early 1980’s and was able to obtain back issues for many years before that. RCMA was started in the mid 1970’s in southern California. In the mid 80’s I was invited to a meeting of the Chicago Chapter of the RCMA by a friend and was hooked instantly. I became IL-370 when I joined RCMA and often submitted info for many of the Midwest states.

The Journal that RCMA published was a small format (5x7 or 6x9 inch) but later it grew to a standard 8.5x11 inch format. When it folded in 1996 remaining memberships were transferred to Popular Communications who had purchased the mailing list. At the time I had a complete collection of RCMA Journals that I wish I still had. As far as I know there has not been an organized effort to digitize the RCMA Journal but if you know of a source, please let us know!

Here in the Chicago area we had to rename our Chicago Chapter due to instructions from RCMA in California. Apparently, they were afraid of liability issues if a remote chapter did something wrong. We renamed ourselves to the Chicago Area Radio Monitoring Association (CARMA) and for several years produced our own newsletter. I was the editor of this newsletter throughout much of its existence and still have copies of the complete set electronically and on paper. CARMA still exists with an email list, Facebook page and occasional meetings.

After the RCMA Journal, my next favorite was Monitoring Times. This was originally published in 1982 with 8 pages and lasted thru 2014. During those 30 years or so it was a great source of information about scanners, shortwave, broadcasting and other radio related topics along with some off-topic stuff humorously tossed in. Bob Grove was the editor the entire time and it was a byproduct of his Grove Enterprises business selling radios and accessories. It was always informative and if one of my friends got his copy before I did, I would often go and read it as I couldn’t wait to get it. I was lucky enough to get published there a few times including a feature article or two. I was bummed when Bob Grove retired and shut down the magazine but as soon as he did Ken Reitz and others came forward and started The Spectrum Monitor with a similar feel and quality.

When the RCMA quit operations, they sold the mailing list to Popular Communications. PopComm, as it was known, was a product of its publisher, Tom Knietel. It was part of the CQ Magazine family. Tom wrote the editorials, some of which actually made sense, and wrote many of the articles and columns under his own name and several others (Alice Branigan, Shannon Hunniwell among others). Later Harold Ort took over as editor and the tone of the magazine became more geared towards general consumer products rather than the radio hobbyists. It was a far less serious publication than MT was, the “reviews” tended to be more of a shill to the advertisers, often an ad for the product would appear next to the “review”.

Tom Kneitel had other schemes going during the PopComm years. One of the most notorious was the “Registered Monitor” certificates he sold with derived “callsigns”. While meaningless, they were a cash cow, and I knew several people who spent good money for a certificate to hand in their office. All-in-all though it was meant to be an entertainment thing rather than anything serious.

PopComm started in 1982, the same year as MT and lasted thru 2013. Some of the content was incorporated into a web-based operation called CQ Plus, which only lasted a short while itself. CQ lasted a while longer, albeit sporadically, until about 2023.

I had a couple bylines in PopComm over the years and enjoyed reading it. It was more entertainment rather than an information source but fun to read.

National Communications is actually still around. Chuck Gysi still produces it, albeit in electronic form only. They ended print publishing in 2012 and last year converted to an article based subscription format. Check them out at National Communications Magazine | Chuck Gysi | N2DUP | Substack

The Spectrum Monitor is a great publication that produces a monthly magazine in electronic (PDF) format that contains a boatload of scanning info by many of the same writers that wrote for MT in the past. I have been a subscriber of TSM since day one and read it from (virtual) cover to cover each month. They have been around since 2014, right after MT left the building. Check them out at www.thesepctrummonitor.com

A couple others were around for a while. Scanning USA lasted a few years. While light on content it made up for it in big fonts and data dumps to fill up the pages.

The Scanner Digest, published by Lou Campagna, seems to have been abandoned since 2015. This was an informative newsletter in electronic form geared mostly to the Northeast. At some point the All-Ohio Scanner Club’s newsletter was merged in the Scanner Digest, AOSC itself had a great newsletter for many years.

I am sure I am missing some others. Incidentally if you go to WorldRadioHistory: Radio Music Electronics Publications ALL FREE you can download many of the magazines I spoke of here and hundreds of other titles. This is an amazing resource for magazines having to do with many facets of the radio hobby.

While paper magazines are only a small fraction of what they once were there are still some still making a go of it. Like printed books however electronic distribution has been making huge inroads. This is true for all kinds of specialty magazines, I get “Trains” magazine as a PDF every month instead of paper. The difference now is that you need to keep an iPad in the bathroom in order to read your favorite magazine.
 

PACNWDude

Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
1,531
Reaction score
764
I admit to subscribing to many of the "scanning" magazines, was nice to read actual print. Still have a garage full of Monitoring times and Popular Communications. Great reading material, and many were kept due to interesting articles or something printed that stood out in that specific issue.

Always amazed me what some hobbyists would uncover while reporters, investigators, and others glossed over the real information, not being technical minded enough to notice reality. (I worked for a company that provided emergency communications services for the oil industry, and hurricanes, flood, and man-made issues would often result in hundreds of radio carrying personnel cleaning up waterways and beaches).

Local news would try to listen in to radio traffic, but was always cued into US Coast Guard and their encrypted 800 MHz radios instead of the analog VHF licensed and publicly searchable frequencies in actual use.

Sometimes, I would see a copy of a scanning magazine, or photo copy of a page or two for larger responses (usually a month or two after the event was over with), in newspaper reporters vehicles. They were trying to listen in.
 

dlwtrunked

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
2,678
Reaction score
1,541
I might mention I just finished read Bob Groves autobiography. Very very little on radio stuff but interesting stories and some about business problems with his company. Since I grew up in NE Ohio (and also went to Kent State), his early days there were also of interest to me.


Amazon also has a books apparently written by him on medical quackery and abnormal psychology.
 

KB2GOM

Active Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2020
Messages
794
Reaction score
675
Location
Rensselaer County New York
I enjoyed reading PopComm and MT, and, as it turns out, eventually wrote for them both. And I absolutely recommend The Spectrum Monitor -- https://www.thespectrummonitor.com/ -- for which I occasionally write.

Tom Kneitel, in my opinion, was the dean of radio writers. He could write a full page about 18 inches of insulated wire and leave you wanting more. I once had a phone conversation with him in which he said "I see my job as 10 percent tell people how to do a thing, and 90 percent selling the romance of doing it at all." I heartily agree.

To me, tuning the airwaves is like a gigantic treasure hunt . . . you never know what you might hear.

I once told K2RHI, a radio professional who controls the repeater on which I run the Commuter Assistance Network -- Commuter Assistance Net -- "the fact that you can talk into a microphone and that someone miles away, unconnected by wires, can hear you is just pure magic, and the sooner you admit it, the better you're going to feel."

And, yes, I miss those printed magazines.
 

dlwtrunked

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
2,678
Reaction score
1,541
...

Tom Kneitel, in my opinion, was the dean of radio writers. He could write a full page about 18 inches of insulated wire and leave you wanting more. I once had a phone conversation with him in which he said "I see my job as 10 percent tell people how to do a thing, and 90 percent selling the romance of doing it at all." I heartily agree.

My problem with Tom was in "selling the romance" he would led truth slide and that rubbed me the wrong way when he tried to hire me and told me mistakes were not to be corrected. So I wrote for MT instead and always considered Bob Grove and honest person who I could deal with.
 

KB2GOM

Active Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2020
Messages
794
Reaction score
675
Location
Rensselaer County New York
My problem with Tom was in "selling the romance" he would led truth slide and that rubbed me the wrong way when he tried to hire me and told me mistakes were not to be corrected. So I wrote for MT instead and always considered Bob Grove and honest person who I could deal with.
I enjoyed both Tom and Bob; never had an honesty problem with Tom.
 

dlwtrunked

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
2,678
Reaction score
1,541

Amazon also has a books apparently written by him on medical quackery and abnormal psychology.
Commenting on my earlier post on that book (Bob Grove of MT autobiography) after reading it. Fun read even if not much radio stuff--lots of stories of other things - often funny.
 

SigIntel8600

Communications Receiver Nut
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 27, 2007
Messages
466
Reaction score
379
Location
Pine Barrens
Pop Comm, MT, USA Scanning, Police Call (listed a a contributing member). I subscribed to them all. I'm an outdoors kind of guy. I used to love sitting by the camp fire, or by the lake or beach, and read my PAPER copy of these publications. I miss them all. I have subscribed to the Spectrum Monitor in the past but I really do not like reading magazines in the digital format. I still subscribe to the NASWA Journal because it shows up in my mailbox, I can take it wherever, and read it where and when I want.
 

mjdewey

Scanner Radio Man, ComL, ComT, Auxcomm
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
153
Reaction score
40
Location
Bluffton, Indiana
I remember subscribing to Monitoring Times, was a member of RCMA and Popular Communications and one other that the name totally has slipped my mind. Every January I went to Radio Shack to get the new Police Call. It was in another city about twenty miles away. Over the years I submitted updates and confirmations to Gene. I also wrote a article that was published in Popular Communications in the 80's.

I also bought alot of books from CRB Research. And I still have alit if them.

I really miss getting these publications in the mail each month. I love the resources on the Internet but they were also the death of these great magazines.
 

N9JIG

Sheriff
Moderator
Joined
Dec 14, 2001
Messages
6,353
Reaction score
5,451
Location
Far NW Valley
I too miss having the paper magazines around at times. I used to have a complete set of Trains (40's thru the 90's), MT, PopCom, RCMA Journal and a couple others but got tired of schlepping them from the old apartment to the new every other year and dumped them. I have since been able to get PDF's of all except the RCMA Journal and they are great for research and recreational reading.

If anyone has copies of the RCMA Journal and the ability to scan them in I would certainly pony up some cash to help make it worthwhile, I am pretty sure we could crowdfund someone to do it.
 

p1879

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 15, 2004
Messages
398
Reaction score
213
Tom Kneital was a driver behind "S9" radio magazine before he started PopComm. The mag was mostly about the CB Radio world, when it was all the rage, but he had scanner and SWL articles as well. I was an active NASWA member back then, and also read the SWL "Utility" newsletter , but can't remember the name of it.

Initially, I was skeptical of many of the low-band VHF DX logs published by "Uncle Tom", but as I explored the band with my first tunable low band VHF radio--and later programmable scanners-- it became apparent he was right. Hearing South African police ops from the US East coast was thrilling--just like Tom said. He piqued my interest in Low-VHF, which is still enjoyed here at the shack.

Tom was also involved with Electronics Illustrated as I recall. Back when Radio Swan/ Radio Americas was a USG operation, based on Swan Island, there was a lot of controversy about Swan being the true location of the transmitters--medium wave 1160 and on HF 6000 KHz (?) as well. Tom and another gentleman chartered a DC-3, and flew to Swan to confirm this, a great story still around on the Net. About everyone on the Island turned out (except the Cubano radio announcers, whom he never saw) to see if the Goony Bird would be able to make the takeoff from the small strip on Swan. Tom wrote several articles on Radio Americas for E.I. Magazine. This was sensational in the day.

The gentleman was also involved with Pop Comm, which had a lot of good literature, especially early on. Pop Comm featured a lot of articles on the huge DEA/ Customs HF nets back in the 80's, and on the comms resulting from war in Nicaragua and El Salvador. The PopComm cover shown in the thread illustrates some of the exciting catches around then....

The adjacent frequencies to the 20M band had all types of strange comms, from smugglers to "contras". Once took my brand new Icom R71 over to a friend's house who was a College Spanish Prof., about 1986, to show it off. We encountered a possible Contra logistics order being read out, in Spanish, just outside the 20M band. Of course, it could have been disinformation to confuse the opposition, but we were delighted to hear of "paletas" (pallets) of 5.56 MM and 7.62 (likely 7.62X39 for AK's) as well as rounds for 81mm "maestros", supposedly mortars. My friend was thoroughly amazed.
 

p1879

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 15, 2004
Messages
398
Reaction score
213
Thank you all for such a trip back into a fading past. Now that I think about it, weren't the Tom Kneital "Registered Monitor Certificates" from the Popular Electronics days? As a kid, I had my WPE4JNL certificate from him, framed and displayed with my QSL cards from short wave stations received from all over the world. This would have been in the sixties, and SWL was the internet of the era-- planetary access via Hallicrafters, for me.

Tom also sold a placard for your car window, perhaps like " US Government Officially Licensed Radio Unit" or some-such. Seems like he intimated that the placard got respect from the Parking Enforcement Cops, unless that is a false memory. I had the placard too, but no wheels .

He was a real inspiration to a introverted science fiction-reading radio wannabe. He cultivated something like an "espionage" persona and drove Jaguar autos. As mentioned in the thread, he artfully made radio fascinating, and the reader felt privy to "inside information".
 

a727469

Active Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2003
Messages
693
Reaction score
567
Location
Maine
I too miss having the paper magazines around at times. I used to have a complete set of Trains (40's thru the 90's), MT, PopCom, RCMA Journal and a couple others but got tired of schlepping them from the old apartment to the new every other year and dumped them. I have since been able to get PDF's of all except the RCMA Journal and they are great for research and recreational reading.

If anyone has copies of the RCMA Journal and the ability to scan them in I would certainly pony up some cash to help make it worthwhile, I am pretty sure we could crowdfund someone to do it.
I have many if not most rcma’s in a bin in my basement but no facilities to copy or scan. I would be happy to supply someone with some of them by year basically for any shipping costs. I will have to check what years I have.
 

VK3RX

Thaumaturge
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Messages
517
Reaction score
381
Location
Australia
I too subscribed to MT & PopComms, even though some of the content was naturally North America-oriented. I still have photocopies of frequency lists from them.

My preference is still paper copies of the mags. I subscribe to. I tend to read them more thoroughly, looking through them multiple times until the next issue arrives. They reside on the coffee table in the lounge, and are skimmed through while watching TV :)

Contrast that with a digital mag I subscribed to, I'd look through it on arrival on a desktop PC and read a few articles, then never look at it again. But then I don't have an ipad or similar , which is probably a factor if they were on it.
 
Top