Wow, the weather must be real bad in Ohio. My ST-2 lasted close to 10 years and I left it on my folks house when I moved out and forgot about it due to being in an apartment at the time (no way to mount) and then Hurricane Sandy rolled thru. Bottom element snapped off but found some 3/16 aluminum rod that fit firmly inside. While right now a small hose clamp is holding it in place. The plan was to use the low head aluminum welding rods and hope for the best, but then I found electrically conductive epoxy and with to many projects going, I put that on hold for now. Also because those plastic insulators mentioned above are showing dry rot and spider cracks and should be replaced. I will be doing those with Lexan and using non-conductive (West Systems) epoxy to make those.
Both of them lasted through one winter and then fell apart. Worked very well until then. This area, Toledo, actually has milder weather than almost anywhere else in an hour's drive. I've had slinky antennas, slopers, both homemade and bought, along with discones, and ground planes, and they all lasted at least a decade unless a tree branch hit them during a storm. My Alpha-Delta sloper lasted about 20 years before water got into the coax from the connector cracking the insulator. One of these days I'm going to make one and since it will be used inside, I would imagine it will last forever.