HI All,
TL;DR: It's my location. It turns out that I am in a reception desert and I have ordered a discone antenna to mount on my ham mast. I guess that makes sense since I have zero coverage from Verizon and Sprint, and one bar for T-Mob and AT&T.
Details:
I work for a local agency and my scanner was programmed by the radio shop supervisor. I took it to the shop and he showed me how to use the Analyze function: Menu->Analyze->System Status->press the Multifunction scroll to display a list of systems, then scroll to choose a site.
At the shop all 3 bars (S=Signal Strength, Q=Decode Quality and A=System Activity) were pegged on the simulcast channel. At my house, S varies from 1-10% and the other two don't move. Same with the "fill-in" repeaters. After a while, apparently the propagation changes, my scanner finally locks in to a county control channel, and away we go. (hence the "warm up" period.)
I Analyzed the other trunk systems and "S" never moves. I'll assume that I cannot receive any of the conventional systems for the same reason that I cannot receive the trunked systems.
So in summary, someone could have recommended that I try using the Analyze function. The radio supervisor thinks the '436 is just better at picking up marginal signals than the '100. Something about how the '100 constantly is playing with the IF, so it never really stabilizes (not sure this is true, but I don't have enough knowledge to question him).
Since I sold the '436 to buy the '100, I never had them side by side to play so I have no idea what S/Q/A looked like on it.