well as a young ham, the old heads in the hobby and their crusty old ways of refusing narrowband, PL tones, and digital modes will die off eventually, wideband is fun to mess around with but is not the solution to our spectrum issues; Rant over
I see no difference between the XL-150P and the XL-185P except that the 185 is intrinsically safe capable. Probably the same damn RF deck.
I love my XL-200, its a fantastic portable and has everything one could desire out of an all-band Phase 2 capable handheld, my only gripe is ****ty audio that doesn't get super loud like my APX.
I hope you told those guys to go piss off...what nerve tryna pawn that crap off on you...