BCD436HP/BCD536HP: Used Uniden prices dropping?

Status
Not open for further replies.

rbluesky

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 6, 2005
Messages
106
Hi I have notice the prices of Uniden scanners dropping on the BCD 436HP, 536HP AND THE 996P2 Any one know why???
I'm looking to get a Bcd 436hp portable
are they a good radio???. Yes I did watch the scanner guys and there 2 new scanners comming out soon
Ron
 

RandyKuff

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,535
Location
Lorain, Ohio
The are great radio's... But depending where you are at and what you intend to monitor. you could have
problems with Simulcast Distortion...
You would need to post what you intend to monitor... Unless you know how to use RR's database to determine
for yourself if the Systems are Simulcast or not...

Just a note: The SDS series are the only scanners that can handle Simulcast Distortion...
 

TJX400

Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
313
The two new scanners are marketed towards railfans and people who want the old fashioned bank operation for analog channels in the newer chassis.
The x36HP series are good radios, as is the 996P2. However, if you're intending to monitor a trunking system that employs simulcast, you will need an SDS radio.
 

RandyKuff

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,535
Location
Lorain, Ohio
Also, if your looking at USED BCDx36HP scanners...
I would want proof (Depending how old they are) that they were sent in for the Repair Campaign for the internal clock and
dimming backlight issue... Or it will cost you to have that repaired... The free repair campaign is long gone and over...
 

rbluesky

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 6, 2005
Messages
106
WOW THANKS for that info Yeah no simulcast here those new scanners have nydn and DMR. NO P25 stupid idea leaving out p25.
Ok I was thinking used but in Crap bay
The sellers dont seem to have all the accessories that pisses me off and they want to much for shipping. I'll buy Brand new unopened. Thanks
Ron
 

TJX400

Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
313
Yeah, I'm not super well versed in trains, but apparently there's a push for all of the railroads to start using NXDN, so that's why it has NXDN/DMR, but not P25.
 

RoninJoliet

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 14, 2003
Messages
3,499
Location
ILL
They made a big mistake not including trunking in the new scanners on DMR-NXDN , your much better off with a 325P2 and purchasing the two modes, there a complete ripoff , my personal opinion .....
 

Bob1955

Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2016
Messages
879
Location
Eastchester, NY
The two new scanners are marketed towards railfans and people who want the old fashioned bank operation for analog channels in the newer chassis.
The x36HP series are good radios, as is the 996P2. However, if you're intending to monitor a trunking system that employs simulcast, you will need an SDS radio.
TJX400-I think you are wrong as the 2 new scanners have NXDN meaning they are also digital and NOT just analog, they are replacing the BCD996P2/BCD325P2 and if I'm wrong, someone correct me.
 

Citywide173

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Feb 18, 2005
Messages
2,170
Location
Attleboro, MA
TJX400-I think you are wrong as the 2 new scanners have NXDN meaning they are also digital and NOT just analog, they are replacing the BCD996P2/BCD325P2 and if I'm wrong, someone correct me.
You are correct on them having digital for NXDN, however they won't replace the 996P2/325P2 because they don't include trunking or P25. This makes it a great entry level radios for railfans as NXDN conventional is being pushed for rail operations but doesn't have the price implications that licensing the trunking operations adds to the price.
 

hiegtx

Mentor
Premium Subscriber
Joined
May 8, 2004
Messages
11,545
Location
Dallas, TX
Hi I have notice the prices of Uniden scanners dropping on the BCD 436HP, 536HP AND THE 996P2 Any one know why???
I'm looking to get a Bcd 436hp portable
are they a good radio???. Yes I did watch the scanner guys and there 2 new scanners comming out soon
Ron
The are great radio's... But depending where you are at and what you intend to monitor. you could have
problems with Simulcast Distortion...
You would need to post what you intend to monitor... Unless you know how to use RR's database to determine
for yourself if the Systems are Simulcast or not...

Just a note: The SDS series are the only scanners that can handle Simulcast Distortion...
I agree with Randy that the 436HP, 536HP, abd the 996P2 are good radios. (So is the 325P2, though it's short battery, life because of only two cells. means it's not as good as a 'grab & go scanner' compared with it's predecessor, the 396XT, though the 325P2 can handle P25 Phase II, which is beyond what the 396XT can do.)

Read through threads in the forums, in both the Uniden Tech Support forum, as well as many of the state forums. You will see a large number of comments that users were unable to find a strategy to deal with simulcast on systems they want to monitor. The various antenna suggestions, and location gymnastics as to exact placement of the scanner, as mentioned in the Simulcast Wiki page could not resolve their issues, so many are posting that they have sold, or intend to sell, their x36HP & P2 series scanners and replace them with one of the SDS scanners in order to hear systems in their area. That does not mean that the scanners they are selling are somehow defective, just that they are not scanner for one or more simulcast systems.

That creates a favorable market members who do not have simulcast issues to pick up a very capable scanner at a lower price than would normally be expected.
Also, if your looking at USED BCDx36HP scanners...
I would want proof (Depending how old they are) that they were sent in for the Repair Campaign for the internal clock and
dimming backlight issue... Or it will cost you to have that repaired... The free repair campaign is long gone and over...
That would be an excellent suggestion. Verify that the x36HP being sold has already had the RTC & display dimness issues addressed, or that the serial number is outside of the range where the problem existed. That, of course, does not positively guarantee that nothing will ever go wrong with your purchase, but at least known issues have been addressed, or the scanner was built past the time period where these problems were prominent.

The only chronic issue that I've seen in the 996P2, from some prchasers, was an issue with receiving Vhf frequencies in the ~170 to ~174MHz range. But that was addressed some time ago via a firmware update. So if that crops up, the fix is already in place via a no cost firmware application, which only takes a few minutes of your time to employ.
 

fxdscon

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 15, 2007
Messages
7,469
TJX400-I think you are wrong as the 2 new scanners have NXDN meaning they are also digital and NOT just analog, they are replacing the BCD996P2/BCD325P2 and if I'm wrong, someone correct me.
.
You are 100% wrong.
These new models do not replace anything - they simply fall between the BC125AT/BCT15X and the next models higher.

This is an entry level unit. It's not a replacement for the 325.
 

Chris0516

Active Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2020
Messages
1,318
Location
Pittsboro, North Carolina
Hi I have notice the prices of Uniden scanners dropping on the BCD 436HP, 536HP AND THE 996P2 Any one know why???
I'm looking to get a Bcd 436hp portable
are they a good radio???. Yes I did watch the scanner guys and there 2 new scanners comming out soon
Ron
I have the 436HP. It is far better on simulcast, than my 325p2 ever was. But, The SDS100\SDS200 is tops.
 

videobruce

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 5, 2004
Messages
463
Location
Buffalo NY
Yeah, I'm not super well versed in trains, but apparently there's a push for all of the railroads to start using NXDN, so that's why it has NXDN/DMR, but not P25.
Where did you get this "push" info from? The general consensus in other RR forums that there is no "push". And considering the carriers have had the radio equipment for probably 10 years and yet to make any switch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top