Washtenaw
Washtenaw is a simulcast system. If you are hearing the state police fine off a tower other than the Washtenaw frequency and everything else is choppy off the Washtenaw tower it's to the system being simulcast.
You don't say if you only have the Washtenaw control channels programmed or if you have several in the area. The Pro-96 and 2096 is not the best on a Simulcast system, the PSR 500, 600 Pro-106, 197 are better but not perfect. The PSR 800 I hear is a bit better. It's an FM Multi-Path issue. The receiver in scanners are not as good as they are in a Motorola radio. Has something to due to the fact of $500 Vs. $3,000. Although the Motorola radios do have problems from time to time on a Simulcast system. All scanners could be better on this type of system but then they wouldn't sell all that well because they would be much more expensive. The scanners are however getting better with each generation.
Search the threads for discussion on Multi-Cast or Simulcast. Basically your scanner is receiving the Washtenaw sytem from several different locations on the same frequency. The scanner thinks it is locked onto a signal and then it sees it again at a stronger level and again and again. On many vehicles without diversity radio tuners in a downtown area you will get a picket fence effect on the audio. The car radio receives the radio frequency then receives it again off the reflection of tall buildings and the effect is heard as on the radio as a choppy signal fading in and out. The scanner issue is much the same however the digital effect is signal, no signal so you miss a lot of the conversation.
What most people find helps is finding a location in your house where it is least affected and or using a beam antenna aimed at one specific tower.
Thia has been discussed for several years here so look around and you'll see what it all means.
Les
I reprogrammed my radio using ARC500. All of state police calls come in loud and clear. Washtenaw county continues to be garbled and choppy. I find it interesting that I can hear action as far away as 1-75 but local stuff not so much. Perhaps you are on to something regarding signal strength?