What is a good scanner under $250?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 9, 2022
Messages
14
Location
Boca Raton, FL
Hi,

I live in Boca Raton, FL. I want to be able to scan the Police, Fire, and EMS near me. I know they use 800mHz channels. What would be a good-priced scanner for this? I don't want to spend any more than $250. Can someone please help me with this?

-RifleMaster650

 

Whiskey3JMC

Just another lowly hobbyist
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Messages
7,789
Location
Philly burbs 🇺🇸
SDR dongle paired with SDRTrunk would be your only option to do the job for under $250. Otherwise expect to spend $350-700 for a scanner capable of P25 Phase-II trunking. Boca Raton Police are fully encrypted as is every other talkgroup ID'ed as mode "DE" or "TE". Lastly the Boca Raton cells are clustered close together so expect some degree of simulcast distortion if you decide against a Uniden SDS100 or SDS200
 

plusEric26

Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
31
Location
Southwest Ohio
You're not going to get a 250 dollar scanner that can scan that system. Closest you might get is maybe something like the BCD996P2 ($399) or something similar, but you might have quite a bit of trouble with simulcast distortion. The only real scanner that is probably worth it right now afaik is the SDS100 or SDS200.

Other options would be to get a few rtl-sdr dongles($40) and use op25 or sdr-trunk or something similar. There a few options from a software prospective, depending on how competent you feel with pc software.
 

BinaryMode

Blondie Once Said To Call Her But Never Answerd
Joined
Jul 3, 2023
Messages
837
Location
75 parsecs away
Check out eBay for the BCD996P2 or BCD325P2 collectively known as the P2 scanners. It's what I did, and well, it's where I buy all my scanners. I haven't bought new for years. Problem is, your area is P25 phase II and thus that means a Trunktracker V type scanner. Well, as Uniden puts it anyway. And that's gonna cost you at least $350.

The suggested SDRs and whatnot will get you to listen on your computer for about $25.

Simulcast distortion may be an issue and in addition to the Wiki entry posted (good stuff) I recently read here on this site a user using more than one antenna to help combat simulcast distortion. This is of course if your stationary at your house or what ever. On the go in a car and whatnot you'll need an SDS type model scanner or the equivalent. But then again, perhaps not since you're moving.

I was curious and did the math. For Palm Beach county there are 218 talkgroups. 80 are encrypted, 138 are unencrypted. Which means for Palm Beach County, 37% encrypted and 63% unencrypted.

There's my nerd post for the day.
 

Whiskey3JMC

Just another lowly hobbyist
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Messages
7,789
Location
Philly burbs 🇺🇸
Thank you. Would the same one work for the New York City Metro region?
Where specifically? It's a huge region encompassing two states. As long as what you're listening to isn't simulcast across multiple cells at same time (or worse, encrypted) then the BCD996P2 or BCD325P2 should do just fine
 

IC-R20

LoBand Nation
Joined
Nov 19, 2018
Messages
511
Thank you. Would the same one work for the New York City Metro region?
Yes, a lot of that stuff is still analog T-band UHF. Brooklyn is slowly turning precincts p25 encrypted but there's still time yet. The manhattan and bronx areas are all still analog for the main channels.
 

brndnstffrd

Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
424
Location
CT
A good choice would be the P25RX or P25RX-II. They work great on simulcast, however a downfall is that while they are great trunking receivers, if you are planning on monitoring both trunked and conventional simultaneously, a traditional scanner would be a better choice. However, if you are looking to just scan one or 2 trunked systems, they cannot be beat for the price. I haven't checked lately to see Todd's availability, however, they are worth keeping an eye out for on the used market until he is able to produce more.
 

RaleighGuy

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
14,678
Location
Raleigh, NC
A good choice would be the P25RX or P25RX-II. They work great on simulcast, however a downfall is that while they are great trunking receivers, if you are planning on monitoring both trunked and conventional simultaneously, a traditional scanner would be a better choice. However, if you are looking to just scan one or 2 trunked systems, they cannot be beat for the price. I haven't checked lately to see Todd's availability, however, they are worth keeping an eye out for on the used market until he is able to produce more.

Or just an SDR and DSD+FL or similar software for under $75 will accomplish the same thing for a lot less.
 

W4KRR

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Apr 1, 2001
Messages
3,485
Location
Coconut Creek
Just an FYI: Boca Raton police are encrypted, as is almost all law enforcement in Palm Beach County.
 

brndnstffrd

Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
424
Location
CT
Or just an SDR and DSD+FL or similar software for under $75 will accomplish the same thing for a lot less.
Not brushing off your suggestion, however the ease of use is definitely a consideration for most people, especially when new. With the P25rx all that is needed is to type in a zip code and just start scanning or just load in a control channel and you're off. The RR import is also a nice feature for the people that use it.

Another benefit to the P25rx is the ability to use it standalone, without a computer. All that is needed is a usb power supply and an audio device.
 

RaleighGuy

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
14,678
Location
Raleigh, NC
Not brushing off your suggestion, however the ease of use is definitely a consideration for most people, especially when new. With the P25rx all that is needed is to type in a zip code and just start scanning or just load in a control channel and you're off. The RR import is also a nice feature for the people that use it.

Another benefit to the P25rx is the ability to use it standalone, without a computer. All that is needed is a usb power supply and an audio device.

Good sell :)
 

ind224

Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
798
Location
Indianapolis
Now now, don't get dismayed the fact the SDS are beyond most casual listeners skill set is a God send. I saw a 200 go for $400 on FBMP and if someone is strapped for cash you might see better than that. Fortunately for me, I don't need Phase 2 just yet and a lady that just bought a Whistler1040 and paid $300 sold it to me for $100 this evening because the ONE county she wants to hear went encrypted.
She could have ISP Indianapolis and other stuff, suprising to me standing in Fishers Indiana with the rubber antenna I was getting Madison Co P25.
Deals are out there.......
 

IC-R20

LoBand Nation
Joined
Nov 19, 2018
Messages
511
Now now, don't get dismayed the fact the SDS are beyond most casual listeners skill set is a God send. I saw a 200 go for $400 on FBMP and if someone is strapped for cash you might see better than that. Fortunately for me, I don't need Phase 2 just yet and a lady that just bought a Whistler1040 and paid $300 sold it to me for $100 this evening because the ONE county she wants to hear went encrypted.
She could have ISP Indianapolis and other stuff, suprising to me standing in Fishers Indiana with the rubber antenna I was getting Madison Co P25.
Deals are out there.......
Yeah it's an insanely hot receiver. I've used it with just the included whip most of the time for years because of that except for specialist cases where I either need LoBand or know around the frequency range I want maximum pull on. Otherwise I keep getting static breaks and weak signals from repeaters and bases far away on the other side of the mountain from me. I got a Diamond RH205 I got for VHF-Hi scanning with it and the reception is unreal at times. That coupled with the long battery life on eneloop pros keep me using it over the TRX1 most of the time when I don't need extra digital modes or to record receptions. The V-Scanner is also great for SIGINT trips because I can make a separate new one for each town I visit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top