Another unit ID question

Status
Not open for further replies.

FDNY10-75

Member
Database Admin
Joined
Nov 24, 2004
Messages
158
Location
Albany, NY
I understand that on a Motorola Type II system you only see the ID of the first unit to transmit and won't see the other UID. Using the trunked system analyzer - current activity tool in the home patrol I am able to see both unit IDs in a given conversation on the same type II system (but I can only hear the conversation with another radio). Is there any way to bridge the gap with a software update so that both UIDs show up during a conversation in a type II system (like they do in a digital system)?
 

GTR8000

NY/NJ Database Guy
Database Admin
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
15,482
Location
BEE00
To clarify:

On a Motorola Type II system, the UID's are sent over the control channel, not over the voice channel. So what happens is, if the conversation on a TG is fluid and quick enough of a transition between radios that the TG holds the same channel grant, there is no way to see the UID because you haven't gone back to the control channel. However, if the delay is long enough between channel grants for that TG and the scanner returns to the control channel, you will see the UID of both units.

So it's not exactly accurate to say "you only see the ID of the first unit to transmit and won't see the other UID", it depends on the delay between users.

In order to "bridge the gap", you would need to somehow simultaneously monitor the control channel to see all of the grants (which includes the UID), as well as the voice channel to follow the conversation when the delay is very short between radios. In other words, you'd need two receivers. It's not a software thing, but a hardware thing.

Remember that trunked system analyzers (Unitrunker, Trunk88, the HP-1, etc.) are dedicated to monitoring the control channel, so they see every bit of activity on the system. They don't monitor the voice channels, so you can't compare what you see using them with how a scanner tracks the system when it has to switch to the voice channels.
 

SCPD

QRT
Joined
Feb 24, 2001
Messages
0
Location
Virginia
It also depends upon whether the system is set up for transmission trunking or message trunking. This applies to both Type II and EDACS systems (but not P25). With message trunking, even control channel analyzers like Unitrunker will only see the first radio ID. With transmission trunking, the software can to see all the radio IDs participating in the conversation.

Here's some info courtesy Wayne.

Message, Transmission, and PTT-ID Trunking

As a side note, P25 only allows transmission trunking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top