DualReverse said:
Fletch,
I take it you're not happy...Is it ProQA you dislike, or NAEMD in its entirety?
Nether really. I am a big believer in pre-arrival instructions. In fact I taught Clawson’s system for 5 years in the early 90’s. I think they contribute to saving lives in the public safety chain of events.
What I, and many involved have disagreed with is the including of the dispatch code, such as 1 Charley 1, in the initial dispatch. It does little to change what is brought into the house on arrival. It’s usually disregarded radio traffic so why include it in the dispatch?
Abdominal pain gets the first in bag and monitor just like any other medical call would. The only thing that makes a real big difference is whether it is an adult or child. That’s why it’s called Pre-Arrival instructions.
Delaware County just north of Columbus has been using ProQA for awhile with supposed success and they don’t relate the protocol codes to the EMS units.
If there is something unusual about the call put it on the printed dispatch sheet or advise the companies as they go in route. Updating the companies with major changes in patient condition during the pre-arrival instructions is good too.
Priority Dispatching is only as good as the training, evaluation, and retraining that is preformed at the dispatcher level. In this case the dispatchers never really “bought into the system” It was forced on them without any input from them. So what that means to the field providers is the dispatch codes are often incorrect. When this happens enough the field providers don’t believe in the system either.
That’s what’s happened at Huber Heights. The system was pushed down the dispatches throats. The field providers were only informed of the implantation 1 week before it started with minimal training on what the system does or how the books work. The administration has been deaf to any suggestions on how to improve the system from not only the dispatchers but the field providers.
One of the biggest concerns by all the line personnel was the departments’ addition of X-Ray calls to the ProQA protocol. An x-ray call requires a third person to get on the Medic for that call. These are supposedly call types we used to send an Engine on for additional manpower. This has been a real flop because a very high percentage of time that 3rd person is not needed for transport, yet this reduces Fire apparatus available to respond during the time the medic is on that call (about 1.5 hours). At least when an Engine accompanied the Medic, if a third wasn’t needed he went back with the pump keeping it in service.
Again, I have nothing against ProQA or NAEMD they are fine groups with excellent programs that work. As anything in life planning and implementation are everything.