I'm wondering if the angle of a system antenna was changed or some other tweak was made to the system recently that introduced simulcast distortion for you. There are some locations where an older scanner will work OK with simulcast, but everything has to be just right. The conditions that allowed your scanner to receive a simulcast system OK before apparently changed. libertydesigns listed options that are made to be compatible with simulcast. You could also go the SDR route with software that works on simulcast. That's cheaper, but requires some IT-related effort.
I'm a little confused by the type of handheld you have. Uniden and GRECOM were competing companies, until GRECOM went out of business several years ago.