You mentioned you are using ProScan, to get a more detailed record you might try while viewing the log grid, checking the very first box in the upper right corner that reads "Each transmission new row".
i checked the FCC site for a coverage map and it seems that each site is supposed to cover about a 20 mile radius around the site, which overlaps close to 90+% . Therefore, the VA site should not be weaker according to this info, unless it is still incomplete. However, I wonder why the cars do not seem to have problems picking up the VA site? The attic ST2 antenna I mentioned is using commercial grade 800 MHz cable with N connectors at each end (not PL259 connectors that leak badly at this freq.). In addition, the cable is only about 5 feet longer than needed.