I really want to recommend the G1, but I don’t think I can. Our department bought 15 of them a couple years ago. Since that time, 3 of them have stopped alerting; the speaker still passes beeps and other sound when you press buttons, but they don’t alert, and you can’t hear any radio traffic. 4 of the G1’s have lost their front buttons; they just….fall off. 1 of the G1’s charging bases melted at the 5v plug in, another one just stopped charging.
Programming in area and mutual aid departments for situational awareness is a huge plus, but we’ve had so many build quality problems, that I think I’d rather have a Minitor.