slowmover
Active Member
I'm not upset with Erik, he is just doing a review on a product.... and his opinion is... it works ok.... he does a great review.. even if I dislike the product.
there certainly is a market for a small antenna.... but these little antenna's only work as good as a child's toy.... maybe not even that good.
so I don't feel they have made a product that actually works.... not yet.... when they can make it look like an 18" antenna and perform better than a Lil-Wil antenna ( not a fan of the Lil Wil, but it will at least get 3 to 4 miles) then it may be, better than no CB at all.
I get many people are not big into the hobby.... but you still need to buy something that works... if I was into the model plane hobby... and they sold a model plane that could fly and be controlled by remote control... that would be the one I would buy... I would not buy one that was less money and looked nicer.... but didn't work!
..... it's pretty difficult to make contacts within just a couple miles of your position today, as people keep buying poor radios and terrible antenna's, even today's truck drivers are lucky to get more than a few miles of range.... so actually making contacts in such a small 2 or 3 mile bubble is very difficult if not pure luck, ...so that is really not going to help anyone to summon help
again just my opinion...
if you think a 2.5 mile CB system can be used for help, traffic or casual contacts... that's your opinion.... I have many little handheld CB radios..... I live in a pretty wooded area.. not a lot of people..... but many highways going through...
since I was a 10 year old kid, 50 years ago I have been trying to get a contact on a handheld CB radio... they're good for about a mile range... in 50 years I've never gotten one contact... NOT ONE ....so my opinion of a small 2.5 mile range antenna is the same opinion of that childhood toy.
my mobile with five foot tall antenna and my base are not toys, and I can easily make contacts at will..... but without a 5 foot tall antenna on the mobile I doubt I could make a contact with anyone... even given another 50 years.
I have many locals all around me on Base stations. they are about 7 miles or more away from me in various directions. I talk to them on my mobile or base often...
because I enjoy testing my little handheld radios I thought maybe they could help me to test them and save me all my filming to see what can be done...... so I often ask them to turn their Squelch all the way down, I then take out a handheld CB and see if they can hear me.... so far no luck
so for me this is real world and those little antenna's just don't work.
Same type of examples work for speaker chosen and its location. Primary
Same type of examples work for attending noise on coax and 12V power. RF Bonds, etc. Secondary.
Hopefully, the hard work and major expense done — primary — then these secondary issues will be attended.
The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
.