Turn off Close Call for now, and see if things improve.
Your problem is not signal strength; it is interference / distortion induced by the signal reaching your radio / antenna from several different transmit sites at slightly different times, aka multipath - which is not good. Radios designed specifically to receive simulcast can compensate for these timing issues.
When experiencing simulcast distortion, your RSSI can be acceptable, but will sometimes appear to drop when multipath effects are particularly pronounced, due to environmental and other factors. Sometimes you will miss entire transmissions. When I had an HP-2 and a Unication radio tuned to the same TG and sitting right next to each other, the HP-2 was at times completely deaf, whereas the Unication was playing the all the traffic.
Your problem is not signal strength; it is interference / distortion induced by the signal reaching your radio / antenna from several different transmit sites at slightly different times, aka multipath - which is not good. Radios designed specifically to receive simulcast can compensate for these timing issues.
When experiencing simulcast distortion, your RSSI can be acceptable, but will sometimes appear to drop when multipath effects are particularly pronounced, due to environmental and other factors. Sometimes you will miss entire transmissions. When I had an HP-2 and a Unication radio tuned to the same TG and sitting right next to each other, the HP-2 was at times completely deaf, whereas the Unication was playing the all the traffic.