- Joined
- Dec 8, 2007
- Messages
- 78
180w Repeater is set to 20w into an amplifier at 180w.Back to the transmitter. What power are you licensed for?
Bill
180w Repeater is set to 20w into an amplifier at 180w.Back to the transmitter. What power are you licensed for?
Bill
It's a HD Sinclair folded dipole array. The mast is probably 1/4" aluminum. It definitely needs the bracing. Unless it's top mounted, and it would need proper clamps for the mass of that antenna. It's definitely not a low budget DB222.I'm not familiar with that antenna. Does it require those braces?
Quick question, where your busy area is, from the tower, is the antenna shielded by the tower?Oh yeah.. That's an entire sinclair kit. When we moved there we had sinclair do some engineering and prop studies and the antenna is made to cover the maximum amount of area with consideration to terrain. I know what model it is as mentioned above. But I know some RF things have been changed. I cannot remember what, but I remember talking to the engineer and this was his recommendation for our site and area. I know there has been some changes from stock or what is seen on their page. And our board bought 2, 1 as a spare just in case.
It would be nice if the upper two supports were non conductive.It's a HD Sinclair folded dipole array. The mast is probably 1/4" aluminum. It definitely needs the bracing. Unless it's top mounted, and it would need proper clamps for the mass of that antenna. It's definitely not a low budget DB222.
No, It's open to that area.Quick question, where your busy area is, from the tower, is the antenna shielded by the tower?
kinda what I figured.Switching to a P25 repeater now with everyone else in our area. Running 7/8 AVA5-50 the feed line to the tower to cabinet is around 360ft into a polyphaser at the cabinet and at the antenna its 8ft off the tower with jumper. the feedline doesn't do and bend till the icebridge on the ground and sweeps clean from polyphaser to antenna.
Also what I figured.5w portables and mobiles at 50w you are correct.
99sq miles isn't really that big of an area to cover.The biggest problem we are trying to overcome is the 99sq mi area in wv mountains with only one site.
What about building another site in your busiest area?The tower is 15mi away from our busiest area.
This... makes no sense. Tower can hear a 5w portable 14 to 15miles away, but the portable can't hear a repeater at about 500w ERP? There is something going on if a portable can't hear a 500w ERP repeater @15miles.The tower can receive 14 to 15mi away on portable. But cannot tx that far to a portable
It seems that it is a huge area in time wise. Our old tower which landowner died and new tennant told us we couldn't use the tower anymore and wasn't renewing a lease it was 2mi to the SE 190ft with a Thunderstick the MTR2000 at 100 or 110 watt and it covered fine on wideband, when narrowbanding came out seems it cut our coverage in half. Now one of the odd things is being at the taller tower farther away, we can talk on a portable in places we couldn't on the older tower... The radio shop that used to take care of us and installed the current radio at the current tower spent days out there trying to figure out what was going on. Still to this day. It's the same thing. And they have no clue.. Even friends of mine that work on DHS radio systems have came out and sat there under a tent and scratched their heads and through their hands up.kinda what I figured.
Also what I figured.
99sq miles isn't really that big of an area to cover.
What about building another site in your busiest area?
This... makes no sense. Tower can hear a 5w portable 14 to 15miles away, but the portable can't hear a repeater at about 500w ERP? There is something going on if a portable can't hear a 500w ERP repeater @15miles.
I see in the spec sheet topmount... Sinclair engineers are the ones that came up with the antenna and mounting configuration. So.. IDK The site just hasn't performed like it should or think it should. I know we are switching to P25 and the repeater needing a pre-selector or not was the problem.. But yet the tower receiving at long distances yet the range of tx is just something we kinda said well it is what it is... Even though it should be better...The spec sheet on that antenna says TOP mount.....
maybe someone can show me something that shows SIDEMOUNT
Never messed with one, dont know
Not disrespecting Sinclair at all, but a project I got sucked into several years ago had the antenna system designed by them. Side mount 800 antennas on 4' standoffs. Coverage was about 30 dB down on the side opposite the antenna. They swore it couldn't be and something must be wrong somewhere else. It cost the project money but we did a temp top mount using about 80' of 1/2" Superflex. Even with the added loss the coverage improved greatly in that direction and was now consistent on all sides of the tower. What works on paper doesn't always work well in the real world.If you can hear better than transmit, a preselector isnt gonna help.
Is poor Tx in all directions from tower?
or maybe just in the line where the tower is blocking the antenna, or in the line on the side of the tower where its mounted.
Engineers, bless their hearts, dont know everything...but yes, they do hold that piece of paper.
That's why I asked about the duplexer.This... makes no sense. Tower can hear a 5w portable 14 to 15miles away, but the portable can't hear a repeater at about 500w ERP? There is something going on if a portable can't hear a 500w ERP repeater @15miles.
DB224 are widely used around here.... However.... Some work better than others.. There's one that was installed on a Sheriff Dept tower only 100ft off the ground and talks all over the county. Then a mile away the Fire Department in that area has one and it will not talk at all.. And just a few weeks ago one of our mutual aid departments got a tower erected that they been working on funding for 10yr and they put a db224 40ft down from top of a 190ft tower. And it's in omni configuration and it will only talk about 6 air mile. Oh and its mounted maybe 18-24in from the tower.. So, I think the 224 are hit and miss, some like them some hate them. Some just don't know...Amen Kevin
Even though DB sold..I still use only Db224 or the now EOL Db228 (love that antenna)
Yes it has downtilt 4 degree. That is to get down in the hollers.. Works there just fine.. This antenna works better than the thunder stick we had before at the same site and it had no downtilt. So, I'm thinking theres something else wrong.. When the antenna was installed all new coax was installed as well. This tower crew did sweeps, performed SWR readings, adjusted things. They took one day to get the old antennas down and the new one installed. The second day to make sure everything was working correctly. Everything has been for the most part, just somethings seem weird especially the rx and tx distances. I've seen the sweeps, I've seen the dense tests, stood right there beside the techs, experienced well known techs, still there is a this ominious problem.Y'all can ignore me if you want (it won't hurt my feelings at all), but back to the antenna. Does that model have a downtilt option? I pulled my hair out over a VHF RFI folded dipole that they accidently sent with a mismarked downtilt phasing harness. Externally it looks just like the regular phasing harness, electrically not so much. And it won't show up on a sweep either. Just a thought.
Not saying it’s the antenna, but that sounds suspiciously like my DT issue. You can’t “see” the downtilt in any sweeps or testing. And without another known good antenna to test against you really don’t what coverage should be.Yes it has downtilt 4 degree. That is to get down in the hollers.. Works there just fine.. This antenna works better than the thunder stick we had before at the same site and it had no downtilt. So, I'm thinking theres something else wrong.. When the antenna was installed all new coax was installed as well. This tower crew did sweeps, performed SWR readings, adjusted things. They took one day to get the old antennas down and the new one installed. The second day to make sure everything was working correctly. Everything has been for the most part, just somethings seem weird especially the rx and tx distances. I've seen the sweeps, I've seen the dense tests, stood right there beside the techs, experienced well known techs, still there is a this ominious problem.
I'd agree, but the repeater hears the subscribers just fine. He's got lots of elevation, but with out knowing the terrain where he is, maybe it's too much gain and the pattern is shooting RF over the coverage area. But with upwards of 500w ERP, you would think that 99sq miles of needed coverage would be saturated and a couple inches of wet noodle would be enough to hear the repeater.Not saying it’s the antenna, but that sounds suspiciously like my DT issue. You can’t “see” the downtilt in any sweeps or testing. And without another known good antenna to test against you really don’t what coverage should be.