P.S.
@mmckenna Ya, there’s nobody more dangerous to public safety comms than CommTech with radio.
I'd narrow that down farther and say "misguided ham with a radio".
Most professional communications techs have enough experience to know better.
While I have radios at work that let me test/talk on several public safety systems, I know what my role is, and it isn't what some hams think.
Whenever I need to test a system, there are a number of things I do FIRST:
1. Make sure the dispatchers and the sergeant know that I'm going to be testing the system and make sure they are OK with it.
2. Make sure they have a way to reach me if they need me off the system.
3. Make sure they know when I'll be starting and stopping.
4. Monitor the system and make sure if the officers start talking, it's time for me to shut the #*%! up.
Even though I have the radios, I never use them to report and emergency. I use a phone for that because that's the way dispatch centers are designed to work. Call taker takes the call, enters it in CAD, hands it off to the dispatcher, dispatcher sends the resources. I'm astounded by the number of hams that will try to make excuses for bypassing the system, as if being a ham radio operator somehow puts them at the head of the line in an emergency. It does nothing but show a lack of understanding and a lack of respect for the professionals.
Trying to help while putting lives at risk. Respect is first priority. If you think you can just buy a CCR and be a first responder, you don’t respect the job, or the people doing the job. We have plenty of hams here in SAR and encourage those already in SAR to get a ham license. I like that a lot because the barrier to entry to SAR is actually pretty high. First aid, CPR, FEMA classes… you have to do a lot more than spend $30 on Amazon!
You said it. I'm troubled by the attitude that buying a radio suddenly makes someone a public safety professional. Whackerism at its finest.
While this has been around for quite a while, I put part of the blame on the ARRL with their stupid "when all else fails" crap. Showed they knew zero about public safety communication systems.
But I hate to take this off course. I'm just tired of the attitude some hams have towards this. Some groups encourage it. Doesn't matter if the FCC makes it abundantly clear, there are those that will think the rules never apply to them.