What is the best ANDROID VHF/UHF Smartphone?

Status
Not open for further replies.

eszumlas1985

Newbie
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 26, 2020
Messages
4
Location
Cross Timbers, Mo.
Ive seen several Two-way transceiver / Android phones out here and was wondering what was the best for picking up VHF and/or DMR transmissions with the best specs and largest display... Any Suggestions? Im looking for something i can use as my everyday phone... So large screen a must and VHF/DMR also a must...
 

Randyk4661

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
579
Location
Garden Grove, CA
I think you are asking for a cell phone that you can use as a walkie talkie and as a scanner as well as a phone? I don't know if the cell phones companies still use something like the old nextel direct connect, someone else might be able to answer that better than I can. I do use an app called Zello that uses an internet connection that works like walkie talkies. It's not radio frequency based.
No cell phone can receive DMR, P25, or analog radio like a scanner. You need to use an app to use something like broadcastify to listen to scanner radio traffic.
I have also used an app called teamviewer to listen to my scanner at the house when I'm out and about.
If you know of something else out there I would like to hear about it.
 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
25,033
Location
United States
Ive seen several Two-way transceiver / Android phones out here and was wondering what was the best for picking up VHF and/or DMR transmissions with the best specs and largest display... Any Suggestions? Im looking for something i can use as my everyday phone... So large screen a must and VHF/DMR also a must...

I know there are some amateur radio oriented products, but never tried one.

For years there have been Chinese companies at trade shows displaying LTE phones with a UHF transceiver in them. Seemed like the worst of both worlds. A 'not very good' phone and a 'not very good' UHF radio. They were all analog UHF at the time, no DMR.

Sonim was playing around with a P25 "sled" that mounted on some of their XP series phones. Have not seen any in the wild, only at trade shows, and even then, that was a few years ago.

Many of the newer, high tier LMR radios are including LTE radios in them. You can go as far as a tri band radio (VHF/UHF/7-800MHz) + LTE + WiFi all in one radio. Usually outside the budget of most ham operators. Harris XL-200 line of radios will do this, but not DMR, only analog + P25. Motorola has some expensive (even for Motorola -expensive-) options in the APX-Next radio.

Rumors of Kenwood coming out with a tri band portable. Knowing them, it'll likely have P25, DMR and NXDN capability plus LTE to keep up with the others. But again, not a phone.

Most of the amateur oriented stuff I've seen has been vapor ware, or so limited/expensive/poorly designed and thought out, that they don't go far. The rest is Chinese junk that I wouldn't waste my time on. Considering the average life span of a phone, I'd not want to invest in something like that.
 

hill

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
1,657
Location
Middle River, MD
Here is one linked below and don't what is the best one, since don't own one. Going forward you would most likely be best to have a cell phone and radio, as not to have them both in the same device.

 

TailGator911

Silent Key/KF4ANC
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
2,687
Location
Fairborn, OH
I got a pair of these for an RV trip to Alaska a while back and love them. Android 7:0 at the time. Only AT&T tho. Rugged and reliable. I had signal on the ferry to Sitka island when no one else did. We also have iPhones on Verizon, but the Sonim XP8 is the better phone, IMHO.

 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
25,033
Location
United States
I got a pair of these for an RV trip to Alaska a while back and love them. Android 7:0 at the time. Only AT&T tho. Rugged and reliable. I had signal on the ferry to Sitka island when no one else did. We also have iPhones on Verizon, but the Sonim XP8 is the better phone, IMHO.



Nice. I'm migrating my work phone over from AT&T to FirstNet and have an XP8 on the way. A lot of nice accessories for those. I just wish it had an external antenna port.
 

Tim-B

Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2016
Messages
531
Location
Down South
So what frequencies are they using for the DMR radio in the ones that are not for Ham like the Atom-XL linked above? I looked at the specs and it says 400-480 MHz. But you can't just transmit on any of those frequencies at your whim. Does it use the FRS frequencies? Can you even do DMR on FRS? Or does it have to be programmed to the frequencies you business is licensed for like any other business radio? I can't imagine it using just random UHF frequencies out of the box and still getting FCC approval.
 

ko6jw_2

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
May 18, 2008
Messages
1,462
Location
Santa Ynez, CA
The RF Finder B1 was reviewed in the November 2020 issue of QST. Received a good report especially for its ease of use on DMR. At just under $1000 I won't be ordering one any time soon. Actually I'd rather have a good dual or try band HT. My iPhone XS Max is fully paid for and it will be a while before I look for another phone. Strangely, not very much local DMR activity here. Very attractive product except for price.
 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
25,033
Location
United States
So what frequencies are they using for the DMR radio in the ones that are not for Ham like the Atom-XL linked above? I looked at the specs and it says 400-480 MHz. But you can't just transmit on any of those frequencies at your whim. Does it use the FRS frequencies? Can you even do DMR on FRS? Or does it have to be programmed to the frequencies you business is licensed for like any other business radio? I can't imagine it using just random UHF frequencies out of the box and still getting FCC approval.

The ones I've seen are programmable, so you'd program it to use whichever frequencies you are licensed for.

It is not currently legal to run DMR on FRS or GMRS. There is one experimental license with a group testing DMR on some specific GMRS frequencies in a very specific area of Central California. That is a test/experiment and does not apply to anyone else except for the group on the experimental license.
 

Tim-B

Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2016
Messages
531
Location
Down South
Ahh, Ok, I was wondering. They made it sound like you just pull it out of the box and start talking DMR.
 

mmckenna

I ♥ Ø
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
25,033
Location
United States
Ahh, Ok, I was wondering. They made it sound like you just pull it out of the box and start talking DMR.

Unfortunately, just like many Baofeng users, some do.

-Real- radios come completely blank from the factory with no way to transmit until programmed. It's the damn Chinese junk radios that come preloaded with random frequencies.

Bastards…..
 

n1das

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2003
Messages
1,601
Location
Nashua, NH
Ive seen several Two-way transceiver / Android phones out here and was wondering what was the best for picking up VHF and/or DMR transmissions with the best specs and largest display... Any Suggestions? Im looking for something i can use as my everyday phone... So large screen a must and VHF/DMR also a must...
 

jaspence

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 21, 2008
Messages
3,041
Location
Michigan
I have an earlier model of the RFinder. It had a couple of early firmware fixes and works okay, but for the cost is not my first choice for a goto radio. The database was not great (being gentle here) but has improved. I can set up a new frequency on my BTech 6x2 using the one of the cell phone repeater programs almost as quickly as with the RFinder. The Android version is stuck at 6.0, and the last security update was August 5, 2017.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top