After reading all your posts, I get that you have ruled out simulcast distortion by using the same programming, location, and antenna as the older 996P2, and still no joy.
Wondering if you tried the Waterford, RISCON, or Suffolk County (New P2 system) systems, I have been in Groton by the water and got all 3 of those on my 996P2
Im 1/2 Mile from a CLMRN site and 1 of my 6 996P2s will not trunk that site but the other 5 will with the ATT on, I'm thinking it might be a better RX than the others, and is getting overloaded even with the ATT on, but I can see a G & A site both around 6 miles away and it works on those fine
Just some food for thought for you, maybe one of my scanner issues is the same as yours?