I have a 96 as well and I can say that on the P25 simulcast systems... it's straight garbage.
I pretty much get the saem as you... virtually nothing. Just a very small "noise" very, very sporadically.
I use the 106 now and it's 10 times better.... but still not as good as the reception on the old system was.
I never got around to messing with the adjustment dials INSIDE the 96, but there was a thread somewhere explaining what someone had done with those dials and reported it helped.
If you're brave, perhaps you can try that and see if it helps.
Overall, my enjoyment of the monitoring hobby has been downgraded dramatically with the swith to the P25 simulcast systme in our local area.
I keep waiting and hoping for the introduction of a new line of scanners that will allow great reception of P25 Simulcast systems.