Did you try tvengr's suggestion? If you can copy the Sheriff on analog, that may be the simplest and best solution.
If you cannot copy the Sheriff via analog freqs, you might want to see if you can isolate the issue to one of the three sites that you're currently monitoring. Assuming that you don't already know which site is giving you the issue--hopefully, it's not all of them--I'd suggest temporarily avoiding two of the three sites, and just listening for the Sheriff on one site at a time. Do this for each of the three sites to see if you can isolate the issue to one site.
Also, if you have access to more than one scanner, you could also listen to each site--one site on each scanner--to see if the transmitted traffic is the same on each site. If all three sites have identical traffic, you could reduce the number of sites you're monitoring which would help if you find that one site is causing the issue. If the issue happens on all three sites, then I'd look for set-up issues on your scanner... like:
-P25 LP Filter setting--see what happens with it turned Off or On.
-Did you return the P25 Threshold back to its default setting or Auto--I leave mine on Auto most of the time.
-Site hold time shouldn't give you the symptoms you're describing, but it couldn't hurt to see what it's set on... I keep mine set to zero.
Did you program it or did someone else? Did you purchase the scanner new or did you buy it used? Sometimes there's some weird setting that a previous owner or a different programmer may have set-up. Starting from scratch isn't fun--unless you're crazy like me--but it can sometimes remedy those hard-to-pin-down issues.
Just throwing a bunch of ideas out there to give you some troubleshooting thoughts.