And confirms yet again, that governments don't get a flying f**k about fiscal responsibility when it comes to spending taxpayer money.
It is well proven that the initial outlay to issue radios to each member is much more fiscally sound than to have pool radios drawn on a shift by shift basis with no accountability when maintenance costs and equipment longevity are factored in. To expect people to carry bulky radios when on call (as opposed to on a call) is not a sound choice from a liability standpoint-insurance rate will probably go up. So you have a few choices:
A. Buy radios for everybody and expect them to carry it-radio gets well taken care of, gives long life and has lower maintenance costs, but since no one wants to lug it around off duty, peopple don't show up at the barn, cellar holes are saved , insurance rates go up and the media keeps asking "where is the fire department?"
B. Issue everyone pagers and have position radios on the apparatus. You get people to show up for the responses, but they may be dealing with a radio where someone taped the antenna over because it was poking them and when confronted, the answer is "I found it like that." The radio is dropped, thrown, used as a hammer and fails at a critical time, possibly endangering the user. I have worked in this system, and no matter how much accountability is attempted, the results are the same.
C. You buy each member a radio and pager. You get better response, both to the station and scene because a much smaller, lighter pager is being worn instead of a large radio being lugged around. The radio is taken care of because the person is responsible for it and can't blame it on someone else. On scene accountability is improved because everyone has a radio, not just the guys who made the station and got the position portables and can hear what is going on, Maintenance costs are reduced by 50% and the radios last years longer than when pool radios were used.
Sometimes fiscal responsibility is spending more in the beginning to keep repair and replacement costs down over time