I own and use an IC-A25 daily at work. Icom, especially their avionics, are known for requiring the EXACT part number to a T or it just won’t work.
For example, headset adapters that look totally identical, fit into the radio as it should wont work. And I’m talking an adapter to its immediate predecessor being the A24.
Just buy the noise canceling external mic for that radio, from Icom. I also use that Icom mic at work under whatever weather graces Ohio, and it works great.
I don’t know much about wiring up mics like you’re describing, but keep in mind that Moto mic is FM and an Icom air band portable is AM. Again, not my wheelhouse, I have no clue if that makes a difference. Just a friendly FYI there.