New York Times: The Wildly Popular Police Scanner Goes Silent for Many

AK9R

Lead Wiki Manager and almost an Awesome Moderator
Super Moderator
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
10,104
Location
Central Indiana
From an article in today's edition of the New York Times.

"The report crackled across the Indianapolis police radio on a recent morning: Two aggressive pit bulls, no leashes in sight, were roaming, a caller complained. Then came an alert about a motorist, possibly armed, en route to Indianapolis, reportedly with homicidal thoughts.

"Later, the police were dispatched to look into reports of overdoses, suicidal people and domestic violence.

"Through it all, hundreds of Indianapolis residents listened.

"Once accessible to a relatively small number of emergency radio enthusiasts who invested in hardware and developed technical expertise, emergency dispatch channels have garnered huge audiences in recent years as websites and apps made tuning in as easy as turning on the television."

...

"Americans have long listened to emergency communication channels. A few decades ago, tuning in required buying a radio, outfitting it with a crystal and learning to set it to the desired frequency.

"That all changed in 2012 after the launch of Broadcastify, a company that gathered thousands of emergency and aviation radio feeds and made them accessible to a constellation of websites and apps. Broadcastify and the platforms that rely on its feeds have free versions supported by ads and premium ones that are ad-free and provide access to archives."
 

Chris0516

Active Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2020
Messages
1,300
Location
Pittsboro, North Carolina
From an article in today's edition of the New York Times.

"The report crackled across the Indianapolis police radio on a recent morning: Two aggressive pit bulls, no leashes in sight, were roaming, a caller complained. Then came an alert about a motorist, possibly armed, en route to Indianapolis, reportedly with homicidal thoughts.

"Later, the police were dispatched to look into reports of overdoses, suicidal people and domestic violence.

"Through it all, hundreds of Indianapolis residents listened.

"Once accessible to a relatively small number of emergency radio enthusiasts who invested in hardware and developed technical expertise, emergency dispatch channels have garnered huge audiences in recent years as websites and apps made tuning in as easy as turning on the television."

...

"Americans have long listened to emergency communication channels. A few decades ago, tuning in required buying a radio, outfitting it with a crystal and learning to set it to the desired frequency.

"That all changed in 2012 after the launch of Broadcastify, a company that gathered thousands of emergency and aviation radio feeds and made them accessible to a constellation of websites and apps. Broadcastify and the platforms that rely on its feeds have free versions supported by ads and premium ones that are ad-free and provide access to archives."
Thank you for posting this.
 

RFI-EMI-GUY

Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2013
Messages
7,533
Back in about 1985 I was on a team that implemented the first Smartnet 1 trunking system for City of Miami. It replaced a UHF conventional system. I had an older neighbor down my street, Dottie Hopwood. She was daughter of a by then deceased NYPD Detective. She was also our well needed and respected neighborhood watch lady (snoop!) as she had a lot of free time and spent hours walking the blocks and feeding cats. She was quite upset that she was now locked out of the scanner world. At the time there were no trunking scanners to be had. I really felt bad then, and now, that I could not set her up as I had the "skillz and warez". It would have been a big conflict of interest and certainly would have gotten out as it turns out she was otherwise very well connected in the community. Her Obit listed commendations from DEA etc.

Whatever anyone might think of police needing encryption, there are people listening that are serving the better good. Dottie was one of them for sure.

 

AK9R

Lead Wiki Manager and almost an Awesome Moderator
Super Moderator
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
10,104
Location
Central Indiana
Why does every reporter think that every police radio "crackles"?
Because that's what they see in the movies. Though, one definition of "crackle" that I found is "to show animation". I assume that using the word "crackle" gives animation to the otherwise lifeless written description.
 

tangier

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
51
Location
Dallas, TX
Back in about 1985 I was on a team that implemented the first Smartnet 1 trunking system for City of Miami. It replaced a UHF conventional system. I had an older neighbor down my street, Dottie Hopwood. She was daughter of a by then deceased NYPD Detective. She was also our well needed and respected neighborhood watch lady (snoop!) as she had a lot of free time and spent hours walking the blocks and feeding cats. She was quite upset that she was now locked out of the scanner world. At the time there were no trunking scanners to be had. I really felt bad then, and now, that I could not set her up as I had the "skillz and warez". It would have been a big conflict of interest and certainly would have gotten out as it turns out she was otherwise very well connected in the community. Her Obit listed commendations from DEA etc.

Whatever anyone might think of police needing encryption, there are people listening that are serving the better good. Dottie was one of them for sure.

Small world indeed ! I was with Coral Gables, FL PD (Miami) in the 70s-80s and Mrs. Hopwood was an avid listener of our radio traffic on the one VHF analog channel we used for years. When we added a UHF business band radio repeater channel (470.8625) for discreet use by our detectives, Mrs. Hopwood quickly found this frequency, discovered who we were and would call the station with "tips" and insight on what she heard. Always enjoyed returning her phone calls. Like RFI-EMI-GUY said, Miami PD's early transition from UHF analog to Phase 1 trunking left a lot of local scanner listeners "in the dark."
 

chrismol1

P25 TruCking!
Joined
Mar 15, 2008
Messages
1,325
Because that's what they see in the movies. Though, one definition of "crackle" that I found is "to show animation". I assume that using the word "crackle" gives animation to the otherwise lifeless written description.
Are you kidding me? So police radios don't have squelch noises when the PTT is pressed and then again when it's released and after receiving every transmission? o_O:eek:
 

INDY72

Monitoring since 1982, using radios since 1991.
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 18, 2002
Messages
14,867
Location
Indianapolis, IN
Are you kidding me? So police radios don't have squelch noises when the PTT is pressed and then again when it's released and after receiving every transmission? o_O:eek:
LOL! Yes, in fact, some do. At least the ones still using analog, especially those on VHF Low Band... (Yes, a quickly dying breed, but yeah they still exist... I still remember when MS Highway Patrol was on low band, and yes, the radios had a short "Ch puh" squelch when you hit PTT, and a "cricket" tail after you let it go, and sometimes yes, the lovely static crackle. Long gone now with P25 Trunking. Does the digital "cricket" sounds on P25 count as a digital crackle? LOL)
 
Last edited:

12dbsinad

Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
2,011
LOL! Yes, in fact, some do. At least the ones still using analog, especially those on VHF Low Band... (Yes, a quickly dying breed, but yeah they still exist... I still remember when MS Highway Patrol was on low band, and yes, the radios had a short "Ch puh" squelch when you hit PTT, and a "cricket" tail after you let it go, and sometimes yes, the lovely static crackle. Long gone now with P25 Trunking. Does the digital "cricket" sounds on P25 count as a digital crackle? LOL)
We went from crackles to sounding like everyone has Covid with digital (and it's possible they do) :)
 

ecps92

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2002
Messages
14,987
Location
Taxachusetts
We went from crackles to sounding like everyone has Covid with digital (and it's possible they do) :)
Crackles just means you need to use some POT Cleaner on the volume control of the old RS2004/2005/2006 Radios

and the Towels are Scratchy too (anyone remember that commercial ?)
 

egftechman

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2023
Messages
87
Thanks for pointing out this article. As someone who's been tuning in two-way communications of all types for almost 4 decades, I would hate to see the complete end of monitoring this stuff....However I think it will eventually come, the next generation of comms will likely be all IP based on dedicated LTE type systems (some utilities are migrating from their trunk systems to private LTE now - Xcel Energy to deploy private LTE network ), and talkgroups will actually be multicast groups and there will be tight data and voice integration in the systems (even with the new all digital trunk systems, most agencies still rely on cellular internet for mobile data), and like the carrier LTE systems, it will likely be natively encrypted...that's just the technological evolution, which means the pressure should be on agencies to provide "official" feeds, regardless of the radio technology used. It's not a cost issue, a PI or NUC on each appropriate line feeding their call recorder and a few kbps of internet access. If Broadcastify really wanted to encourage such, they should offer free managed recording services in exchange, which would actually save local agencies thousands each year (price out NICE recorders, a small agency can easily be $50K into it, plus yearly license fees)..

The other thing that is happening is since mobile data devices are extremely common now, most of the "meat" is being sent via MDT or other messaging and not voice, so the amount of information from listening is becoming more limited, and what is heard over voice channels is more "en-route", "on-scene", "10-8" type stuff and not much more.
 
Top